Two Bagel-Sandwich Meals at Bagel Jay's Bakery and Cafe

Multiple Locations

90% of 331 Groupon Customers Recommend

Give as a Gift
Over 860 bought
Limited quantity available

The bagel, like the circle from which it takes its shape, is a metaphor for life—it literally never ends. Enjoy eternally enticing eats with this Groupon.

$9 for Two Bagels or Bagel Sandwiches (Up to a $7.99 Value Each) and Two Drinks (Up to a $1.79 Value Each; Up to a $19.56 Total Value)

In addition to bagels in flavors such as tomato pesto and chocolate chip, the café menu showcases muffins and numerous sandwiches, such as a hummus wrap with feta and olives.

Bagel Jay's Bakery and Cafe

Like Prometheus stealing fire from the gods to give it to humankind, the founders of Bagel Jay's Bakery and Cafe brought bagels to Western New York in 1976. Since then, owner Bagel Jay has been crafting circular standbys with a menu of freshly baked bagels paired with savory deli meats. Diners dress their hearth-baked bagel with cream-cheese shmears of scallions, vegetable, and cinnamon honey, or construct sandwiches of sliced roasted turkey, hot corned beef, or ham. A steaming cup of Jakee's Java and a breakfast bagel with bacon and cheese help jump-start the morning, and classic tuna salad fortifies muscles after a long day of playing Jenga with railroad ties.


Tips from Groupon Customers

  • “GREAT SANDWICHES, THE BEST. FAST AND POLITE SERVICE. EVERYTHING PRICED RIGHT.”

  • “Food was fresh and good and the service by the owner was excellent.”

  • “Absolutely wonderful selection & delicious food! Great, friendly service!”


  1. A

    Buffalo Location

    2130 Delaware Ave.

    Buffalo, New York 14207

    716-874-1800

    Get Directions
  2. B

    Williamsville Location

    100 A Plaza Dr.

    Williamsville, New York 14221

    716-639-1000

    Get Directions
  3. C

    Getzville Location

    2206 Millersport Hwy.

    Getzville, New York 14068

    716-204-0001

    Get Directions

In a Nutshell

Specialty sandwiches made on New York–style, hearth-baked bagels with slices of roasted turkey, hot corned beef, or ham

The Fine Print

Expires May 8th, 2013. Limit 1 per person, may buy 1 additional as gift. Limit 1 per visit. Valid only for option purchased. Must use promotional value in 1 visit. Merchant is solely responsible to purchasers for the care and quality of the advertised goods and services.

Uncomplicated dining experiences that won’t waste your time or budget
Small treats such as cupcakes, magazine subscriptions, and deli punch cards