Food & Drink in Bay Shore

Select Local Merchants

T.J. Finley's Public House has been reviewed by The New York Times. Yelpers give it an average of 4.5 stars and 91% of over 20 Urbanspooners recommend it.

42 E Main St
Bay Shore,
NY
US

The culinary maestros at Molly Malone's Pub & Restaurant perform a satiating jig on voracious taste buds with a menu that fuses Irish, American, and continental flavors. Like a bald eagle wearing a red wig, an order of fried sea scallops and French fries ($19.99) from the dinner menu boasts an Irish-American flare, while the corned beef and cabbage ($11.99) lunch specialty rewards loyal mandibles with an authentic Irish delicacy (see full menus and prices). Diners can feast their ears on a rotating docket of live performances.

124 Maple Ave
Bay Shore,
NY
US

An unmistakable elegance permeates the dining room at New Peninsula Restaurant. Armless, checker-patterned chairs surround tables blanketed with crisp linens and gleaming silverware, and two milk-white horse statues stand mid-canter amid the lush greenery of the room's potted plants. With sporadic lanterns and track lighting casting a dim glow throughout the space, the shining, cerulean-blue aquarium stands out like a beacon. Overhead, the recessed ceiling features pinpoints of light against a blue-black background, mimicking the appearance of a nighttime sky or a Magic Eight Ball full of fireflies instead of advice.

Within this distinct setting, New Peninsula Restaurant's chefs indulge diners with a menu of pan-regional Asian cuisine that mainly draws inspiration from Chinese and Japanese culinary traditions. Sushi chefs fill plates with nigiri, sashimi, and more than 40 different rolls while the rest of the kitchen prepares classic dishes such as steak teriyaki and stir-fried soba noodles with chicken. Chinese dishes include Peking duck, roast pork lo mein, and shrimp in spicy Szechuan sauce.

55 W Main St
Bay Shore,
NY
US

Yelpers give Bubba's Burrito Bar an average of 3.5 stars. Eighty-three percent of Urbanspooners recommend it. More than 1,000 Facebookers like it.

513 Main St
Islip,
NY
US