Fishing in Coney Island

Select Local Merchants

Established: 2013

Reservations/Appointments: Required

Staff Size: 2?10 people

Average Duration of Services: 4+ hours

Handicap Accessible: No

Parking: Free street parking

Recommended Age Group: All ages

Pro Tip: Always dress in warmer layers, as you can take clothes off.

Across a 100-foot main deck, passengers cast their lures into Sheepshead Bay from the wide aisles, benches, and extended pulpit of the Ranger VI. With the help of three 650-horsepower John Deere engines, Captain Joe steers the fishing boat out onto the salty waters for half- and full-day fishing trips. He also captains overnight and offshore specialty charters for up to 20.

Inside the boat, his passengers take advantage of restrooms with running water and purchase refreshments at the galley before seating themselves at tables and booths. Plus, they can head up to the second-floor sun deck in order to better search for marine life and befriend seagulls.

Pier 4
Sheepshead Bay,
NY
US

Captain Jeff and his mates pilot two vessels through the waters that lap New York’s varied shorelines, hunting fish the old-fashioned way—with rod and reel—on daily scheduled trips as well as private chartered voyages. This pair of ships forms the entirety of The Bullet Fleet, which provides deep-water excursions for salty dogs and newcomers alike. Onboard, passengers receive all the necessary gear and a modicum of instruction, as the crew takes a sink-or-swim approach to learning to fish, much like Sir Isaac Newton’s attempts to teach an apple to fly.

Pier 1 Sheepshead Bay
Brooklyn,
NY
US

About the 55’ Capt’s Lady charter-fishing vessel, fishers of all experience levels angle for fluke, striped bass, bluefish, or porgy in Brooklyn’s Sheepshead Bay. The boat’s twin Detroit Diesel engines keep things motoring while an experienced crew of happily grizzled seafarers make the experience fun and easy. When they’re not helping newcomers get used to fishing’s nuances, they’re happy to answer other questions; go ahead and ask them about the biggest fish they’ve ever caught, or about that time they mistook the Statue of Liberty for a really big mermaid. Recently renovated, the ship also includes creature comforts such as an onboard bathroom, snack bar, and cabin seating.

Famous Sheepshead Bay
Brooklyn,
NY
US

Freedom Cruises seasoned captains and crews glide along New York’s aquatic highways during scenic cruises and fishing journeys throughout the week. The company’s roster of aquatic sojourns includes the comprehensive New York Harbor Sightseeing Cruise, which enables guests to take in the city’s most iconic buildings from a unique perspective without holding a helicopter pilot’s collection of sunglasses the whole time. The weekend Brunch on the Bay cruises leave the sounds of live DJs and aromas of buffet-style brunch in their wake as they float past Coney Island. During Fourth of July cruises, ships sail beneath fireworks displays, so that the glittering sparks seem close enough for passengers to catch them on their tongues.

2100 Emmons Avenue
Brooklyn,
NY
US

Loaded down with affable gangs of amateur fishermen, the Lady Midnight and her sister ship, the Captain Midnight, set off from Brooklyn's Pier 1 for full- and half-day charter fishing trips. After hooking the provided bait, passengers drop in their lines and patiently await bites from species such as fluke and porgy in the summer or blackfish and ling throughout the rest of the year. On the trip back to port, the boat's deckhands assist with cleaning and packaging the fresh catch. Owners can then take home their catch to toss on the grill or use to catch an even bigger fish in their bathtub that doubles as a lake.

Pier 1, Sheepshead Bay
Brooklyn,
NY
US