Italian Restaurants in Coney Island

Select Local Merchants

Scot Cosentino and the Goodfella's team share their love of pizza and pasta with guests at their family-friendly Italian bistro. Pizzas made in the old-world tradition—i.e., cooked in a real wood-fired brick oven as the chefs quote Dickens—include Cosentino’s original vodka pizza and other handmade pies. For these gourmet pizzas, Goodfella's has taken home big prize money from the International Pizza Expo, winning its Pizza Challenge on more than one occasion. The chefs also prepare heaping helpings of Italian pastas and entrees, such as prime-cut angus steak and linguini with baby clams.

1718 Hylan Blvd
Staten Island,
NY
US

Salvatore of SOHO's handmade neapolitan crust are covered in authentic toppings and fired in its custom-built coal-fired brick pizza oven, creating perfectly crisp crusts for pie aficionados. Mozzarella crafted each day, san marzano tomatoes, and organic farm-grown spices and herbs smother the limelight on the chewy, smoky crusts, with a classic menu singing backup.

1880 Hylan Blvd
Staten Island,
NY
US

SILive praised Angelina's Ristorante. Eleven Yelpers give Angelina's an average of 3.5 stars. More than 1,200 Facebookers are friends.

399 Ellis St
Staten Island,
NY
US

It’s more than just gooey, melted mozzarella on bubbling pizza. And it’s more than a long list of 29 sandwiches including meatball parmigiana and BBQ grilled chicken. Johns Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant has brought these dishes and more to thousands of events since opening in 1989. For offsite soirées—such as the ones they catered for the New York Police Department and Staten Island University Hospital—Johns can also provide tents, tables, and chairs that make planning a party so easy that some might want to start celebrating their birthday three times a year. Alternately, customers can dine in at their pizzeria, choosing from a menu of nearly 20 salads as well as seafood entrees and crowd-pleasing pizzas.

126 Lincoln Ave
Staten Island,
NY
US