Italian Restaurants in Conneaut

Select Local Merchants

Anchored by its fresh-baked dough made from scratch from an old family recipe, Papa Joe's pizzas conquer hunger with their formidably large size and plethora of toppings options. Crusts can be rolled thick or thin, then topped with a traditional red sauce, pink sauce, spicy ranchero, or garlic and oil. Carnivorous cravers might opt for meaty toppings such as pepperoni, sausage, bacon, or chicken, and herbivorous appetites will pine for layers of spinach, mushrooms, or jalapeño peppers resting on a mozzarella bed. This Groupon is good for carry-out and dine-in, though those looking to enjoy a relaxing meal in Papa Joe's casual dining area can also take advantage of the free WiFi, ideal for quickly settling heated dinner debates over whether New Delhi is the capital of India or Indiana.

402 W 8th St
Erie,
PA
US

In 1972, Joseph Catanese created Giuseppe’s Pizza & Subs on the square-crust foundation of Sicilian-style pies and oven-roasted sandwiches. Like their dough, the chefs in Giuseppe’s kitchen rise early and often, making breads from scratch daily. Their pizza canvases also fuel the efforts of other local eateries by providing them with pre-baked crusts and frozen dough balls, which are also ideal for training for an upcoming basketball-eating contest.

6966 Heisley Rd
Mentor,
OH
US

Seven Facebookers give Molta Bella Pizza an average of five stars, and the pizzeria boasts more than 330 fans:

37812 Vine St
Willoughby,
OH
US

Inside The Wild Goose, which won the people’s choice award from the Taste of Willoughby, a stone oven bakes pizzas laden with eclectic ingredients, including elbow noodles, celery, and potatoes. Chefs top the Galway Bay pie with alfredo sauce, rock shrimp, crabmeat, cheese, and a sprinkle of parsley, and they slather the That’s A Buff Chick pizza with chicken, cheese, celery, crumbled blue cheese, and a drizzle of buffalo sauce. When not customizing crusts, they ladle up bowls of irish potato soup and fill hoagies with saucy meatballs as pro football games and amateur potato-peeling competitions play on televisions propped behind a granite-topped bar.

4144 Erie St
Willoughby,
OH
US

Cala's Pizzeria features a menu stacked with cheesy, fried, and saucy savories. Tantalize tongue buds with starters such as breaded mozzarella cheese sticks ($4.99) or Cala's signature jumbo wings, extra-large hunks of meat stuck to the bone, deep fried to crispy resistance, and generously slathered, like a store-bought baby, in one of ten flavor-packed sauces ($9.99 for 15). Multiple varieties of pizza baked to order are known to emerge from ovens ($9.99 and up for large 12-inch), and specialty pizzas such as the bacon-double-cheeseburger and Italian-meatball pizzas will appease variety-seeking diners ($10.99/small, $14.99/large, $17.99/family). Cala's french-bread pizzas fuse the flavors of two highly haughty cuisines into a cheesy sandwich ($5.99 and up).

31800 Vine St
Willowick,
OH
US

CiCi’s Pizza combines the variety of a family-friendly buffet with the thrill of bottomless pizza. Each pie is crafted with dough made from scratch daily and then slathered with homemade marinara and showered with toppings ranging from traditional pepperoni and Italian-style sausage to creative combinations including buffalo chicken and mac 'n' cheese, resulting in more than 28 signature pizzas. The buffet is stocked with a plethora of fresh pastas, such as cavatappi noodles with classic marinara or alfredo sauce, as well as fully customizable signature salads. After they've feasted on savory options, diners can revisit the buffet for dessert including freshly baked brownies, slices of apple pizza, and cinnamon rolls drizzled with icing—or they can eat dessert first, thereby tearing an irreparable hole in the space-time continuum.

1920 Niles Cortland Rd SE
Warren,
OH
US