Italian Restaurants in Crestwood

Select Local Merchants

Despite the name, Simply Slices parcels out pizza in nearly any form desirable—by the slice or by the pie, and for dining in, picking up inside, or driving through. Pie twirlers heap a selection of 13 ingredients on crust spread thin, fluffed to form a deep basin, or stuffed with toppings. Meanwhile, sister store Sno Biz pipes in sweet shaved ice to accompany special combos that get customers more food for their dollar or doubloon.

14208 Cicero Ave
Crestwood,
IL
US

Nonna’s Pizza

The rules to Nonna’s Challenge are deceptively simple: eat two slices in half an hour. Every last bit of pizza must be finished, and you can only get up from the table to refill your drink. So what’s the catch? Well, for starters, the slices are gargantuan––each constitutes a quarter of a pie and measures nearly an inch thick. None of this could dissuade pizza aficionado Tim Brown, who polished off two slices in less than four minutes. Thankfully, not all meals at Nonna’s Pizza have to be so intense. Though the pizzeria has been serving up enormous slices for more than four decades, its menu has a lot more to offer. Hearty pastas, 8-inch Italian sandwiches, and sauce-slathered wings are just some of the dishes that fill tables beside the dining room’s large picture windows. Nonna’s even brews a special house cola, which gets its distinctive spice from being fired in the same oven as the pizzas.

13636 Cicero Ave
Crestwood,
IL
US

2 Goomba’s Italian Ristorante is an eatery that draws on generations of family recipes for its menu. Pastas here are housemade, and pizzas come topped with fresh ingredients, imported meats, and a blend of freshly grated cheeses. If you’re dining in, take advantage of the restaurant’s BYOB status and bring a bottle of wine, a six pack of beer, or a pail of milk.

13440 S Ridgeland Ave.
Palos Heights,
IL
US

At Jullianni's, friendly staffers rush mozzarella-strewn pizzas, wings, and nachos to each table and booth in their open dining room, which is furnished with a high ceiling and sleek wood accents. Diners can also sate cravings for subs or idiosyncratic flavors such as crab cakes with banana-pepper tartar.

7239 W College Dr
Palos Heights,
IL
US

Caprio's offers a complete menu of items for every type of event; from an evening get-together to the largest family and corporate events. Caprio’s Pizza & Catering offers dine-in, delivery, carryout, and catering.

12778 S Harlem Ave
Palos Heights,
IL
US

Crestwood Scene