Italian Restaurants in Eatontown

Select Local Merchants

For 36 years, the kitchen at Ruffino's Restaurant has crafted specialty pizzas and flavorful Italian dishes ranging from shrimp scampi to chicken marsala. Eggplant supplied by local farmers goes into fresh eggplant parmigiana, and years of culinary tradition go into classic dishes such as baked tortellini.

178 State Route 35
Eatontown,
NJ
US

Tommy's Coal Fired Pizza introduces the "old world" art of Pizza Making. At Tommy's we carry on this tradition by using only the finest ingredients for our Pizza. Our Pizza is baked in a coal fired oven at temperatures exceeding 1000 degrees providing an authentic crispy crust that enhances our top quality toppings.

2105 State Route 35
Oakhurst,
NJ
US

The dough slingers at Uncle Carmines University dish-up 16-inch rounds loaded with cheese to form the bulwark of meals. Like the best break-dancers, Cluck-U wings are boneless and wearing a spicy outfit of one of seven sauces, graded by heat. Mild-mannered tongues opt for honey hickory, and the bravest of taste buds prove their mettle with a thermo-nuclear sauce, with a two-liter soda on call to prevent mouth meltdowns. Game-day hosts peruse the ample catering menu to order trays of penne alla vodka ($35/half tray; $65/full tray), and monster-mash hostesses request a meaty london broil loaded with potatoes, onions, and garlic to keep vampires from hogging the bag toss ($55/half tray; $100 full tray).

1215 Wyckoff Road
Wall Township,
NJ
US

Brothers Paul and Matthew Zappoli and friend Michael Cacciuttolo went out into the world to make their fortunes, but a chance to build something together brought them back to New Jersey. A friendship that began on a Little League baseball diamond has now taken root in Tre Amici (or "three friends"), where the trio serve Old World comfort food in an inviting and comfortable environment. Chef Matthew Zappoli, a 2010 winner of Food Network's Chopped expertly plates Italian favorites, such as chicken piccata or veal parmesan. Each bite attests to epicurean abilities, honed at the Culinary Institute of America, that have earned the chef praise from Bon Appétit and appearances as the featured chef at The James Beard House.

Hand-crafted pasta lounges in fresh sauce, and local ingredients make up appetite-trouncing accouterments. On some weekend evenings, warm tangles of guitar notes drift from the playing area laid out before the wood-burning oven. And a row of outdoor seats lets diners bask in the sun or maintain the hope that a lost kite will still come back.

628 Ocean Ave
Long Branch,
NJ
US

The family that owns La Famiglia Pizzeria prepares Italian recipes passed down through the generations. The chefs bake square Sicilian-style pies and thin-crust pan pizzas, layering fresh, housemade dough with flavorful toppings such as meatballs, grilled shrimp, and other proteins. They also toss pasta with made-from-scratch sauces and assemble light paninis or hearty cheesesteaks. In the warmer months, diners can take advantage of outdoor seating.

522 Atlantic Ave
Long Branch,
NJ
US

The staff at John’s Pizza served their first hand tossed pie more than a decade ago and have been twirling dough ever since. Today, the menu contains an array of hot and cold subs, along with baked pasta dishes. Chefs top 16-inch pizzas with crisp veggies and meats such as sliced meatballs. Diners can enjoy slices inside the dining room or take their pizza to go with take-out and delivery options.

229 3rd Ave
Long Branch,
NJ
US