Italian Restaurants in Elmira

Select Local Merchants

Fabio's Italian Restaurant appeases appetites of all sizes and styles with a well-equipped kitchen and staff prepared to make fresh, authentic Italian cuisine to order and serve it up family-style. Hungry taste buds can peruse the comprehensive menu in search of pastas, Italian-style seafood, and sandwiches, while mouths in search of lighter fare can please their palates with heart-healthy creations that feature leaner proteins. Cast off on a Mediterranean meal cruise with a tongue-tempting appetizer, such as an order of stuffed portobello mushrooms, each brimming with fresh mozzarella, basil, and fresh diced tomatoes ($5.50). Entree options squelch the wild urges of untamed canines with savory forkfuls pan seared veal piccata plate-paired with capers and mushroom ($24.50) or tightly wound fork-spools of spaghetti alle cozze with sautéed black mussels ($22.50). Pay homage to Italy’s rich peninsular past with the Italian-style grilled tuna steak, which combines aquatic life and detailed preparation, much like the mermaid-themed mosaic in the Sistine Chapel’s lost and found office ($23). Complete culinary equations with flavor-flattering sides such as sautéed vegetables ($6) or homemade pasta slathered in alfredo or meat sauce ($6).

179 Homer Ave
Cortland,
NY
US

Brothers Fausto and Massimo Albano, natives of Vaglio Basilicata in Southern Italy, merged their hospitality skills with the culinary prowess of chef Giovanni Castelli, Jr. and pizza chef Gianluca Isopi to forge the diverse dishes and elegant air that defines Prosecco. In an upscale atmosphere awash in colorful curtains, eclectic stone accents, and fresh greenery, the staff serves up a menu of authentic Northern and Southern Italian specialties at both lunch and dinner. Cioppino alla gio, a house specialty merging shrimp, clams, mussels, and scallops with zesty spices in a light tomato broth, parades alongside tender gnocchi and bubbling pizzas, each forged from scratch and slathered in house-made sauces. Drinksmiths at the full bar sling signature cocktails, draft beer, and more than 30 wines as jazz melodies meander from the instruments of live performers and the crystal of overconfident wine glasses nearly every night.

1550 Route 332
Farmington,
NY
US

Hometown Pizzeria, winner of Taste of Baldwinsville's People's Choice for Best Pizza, adorns its hand-tossed dough disks with a sorting of never-frozen ingredients and fresh toppings. The mighty menu includes a gastronomic glut of gourmet pies, ranging from the cheeseburger-and-fries pizza, a zesty ketchup and mustard spread layered beneath a bundle of police evidence auctioned from the Hamburglar's knapsack ($11.99/medium), to the oriental-chicken pizza piled with teriyaki chicken, cabbage, and roasted almonds ($11.99/medium). In addition to a selection of sandwiches ($3.69+) and custom calzones ($5.09+), Hometown also stocks a flock of more than 10 flavors of signature grilled wings, including honey barbecue and taki zesty orange ($6.90 /10). This Groupon is good for dine-in, carryout, delivery ($1 delivery charge), or teleportation.

2119 Downer Street Rd
Baldwinsville,
NY
US

Siena showcases traditional American dishes and beverages in a casual atmosphere. The menu features crisp salads, hot sandwiches, hearty pastas, and appetizer platters anointed with innovative flavors. Whet black-tie appetites with the shrimp cocktail, a cavalcade of crustaceans poised to dive into a pool of house-made sauce ($8.50), or sink teeth into a meatball hero sandwich ($8.95) loaded with saucy, spherical morsels. Pie-eyed diners can craft the personal pizza of their dreams with a choice of sauce, cheese, and creative toppings, such as artichoke hearts and sun-dried tomatoes ($8.95). Hungry crowds hone their cutlery skills by scooping forkfuls of gnocchi bolognese, pillows of potato dumplings sautéed with sage, garlic, and browned butter ($13.95); cutting into the NY strip steak ($16.95); or spooning French onion soup until it falls asleep.

5633 W Genesee St
Camillus,
NY
US

The pizza pros at SoNo's Pizza and Pasta Factory bake up a menu of sizzling pastas, sandwiches, calzones, and pizzas forged from freshly mined dough and sauce. After visiting the pizza oracle for inspiration, SoNo's has emerged with 27 styles of pizza, such as the spicy honey bbq chicken, piled with baked chicken covered in homemade honey barbecue sauce, mozzarella, cheddar, jack, and sauteed onions ($18.99+), or the baked lasagna, a pie that’s clothed in penne, meatballs, sausage, ricotta, and mozzarella ($18.99+). Patrons who don’t eat pizza can order chicken parmesan ($8.99) or a meatball wrap ($5.99), or choose to chew on a dozen wings doused in their choice of 19 flavors including Jack Daniels glaze, lemon garlic pepper, and sweet and sour ($6.95).

18 West Main street
Marcellus,
NY
US

The menu at Canale's Italian Cuisine?a family-owned restaurant more than 60 years old?reads like a well-loved scrapbook. Its notes describe the food and its history: "Homemade gnocchi prepared with Ma Canale's recipe from Morolo, Italy," or "Anna's [tomato sauce] recipe, prepared exactly as she taught us back in 1954." Given these personal touches, it's no surprise that the menu has a Family Favorites section that spotlights classic entrees. These include homemade fettuccine, rigatoni with shrimp, and of course, spaghetti with meatballs or Italian sausage ("Canale's most popular dish").

For meals at home, the kitchen prepares "parties to go"?packages of pizza or chicken wings. You can also find Canale's sauces, dressings, and frozen dinners at dozens of grocery and misguided shoe stores in the area.

7421 Oswego Rd
Liverpool,
NY
US