Seafood Restaurants in Fairview Heights

Select Local Merchants

Though it sits squarely in St. Louis, Broadway Oyster Bar might as well inhabit New Orleans. Even from the outside, the 150-year-old building exudes the revelry of the French Quarter, as an art-deco neon sign emblazoned with music notes joins colorful string lanterns to form an illuminated invitation for patrons to come in and live a little. Of course, inside is where the Cajun atmosphere is most apparent, especially in whiffs of dishes named the favorite Cajun/creole cuisine of the Sauce Magazine readers? poll every year since 2003. Chef Brad Hagen's acclaimed recipes include marinated alligator with homemade tartar sauce, shucked oysters topped with spinach cream sauce, and fresh-baked Gambino's bread filled with traditional po' boy fixings, such as fried catfish and shrimp. Feasts unfold in a cozy dining room or an open-air patio enclosed and heated in winter. There, local and national musicians grace the stage seven nights a week to play funk and blues tunes, just like Mom used to.

736 S Broadway
Saint Louis,
MO
US

Joe Sanfilippo got his start in the food industry at age 11 when his Uncle Agostino recruited him to bus tables at his St. Louis restaurant on a particularly busy New Year’s night, according to St. Louis Magazine. Two years later, he returned to his hometown of Palermo to study and to attend culinary school at night, which ignited his passion for cooking and spurred him to open his own eatery at the tender age of 24. Today, the owner and executive chef of J.F. Sanfilippo’s Restaurant mingles his southern-Italian training with northern-Italian influences in a menu of pastas with tomato- or cream-based sauces, sautéed chicken and veal, and broiled steaks. In a recent KSDK 5 interview centering on the opening of his second location in Chesterfield, Joe confided that his 80-year-old mother still bakes the restaurant’s bread each day and divulged plans to bottle and sell J.F.’s popular vodka sauce, then ship it to Neptune.

705 N Broadway
Saint Louis,
MO
US

On weekends between 10:30 a.m. and 3:00 p.m., a cart laden with plated dim sum rolls through Lu Lu Seafood, delivering handcrafted treats such as pork shu mai or spare ribs in black bean sauce. Patrons can also dine on regional Chinese seafood such as live lobsters with ginger and scallions or hot pots simmering with fresh scallops, washing it all back with cocktails, smoothies, and milk tea laden with pearls of tapioca. The opulent crimson-and-gold eatery also houses private karaoke rooms with bottle service where guests can sing in English, Chinese, or Korean.

8224 Olive Blvd
Saint Louis,
MO
US

When Agostino Gabriele was the executive chef at the Chase Park Plaza Hotel in 1965, inventing a dish called mare monte, he probably didn't expect that one day his son would be preparing the same dish in a restaurant bearing his name. But that's just the case?today, at Agostino's Italian Restaurant, son Paul serves as the executive chef. And in his father's former kitchen, he and his staff fill plates with tangles of linguini, shrimp, clams, and veggies using that nearly 50-year-old recipe. The rest of the menu follows suit with Italian style, from the opening appetizer (toasted beef ravioli) to the meal-ending desserts prepared in-house (cannoli, cassata cake). Of course, this family-owned establishment has a banquet room for other families to celebrate their own memories, such as when Uncle Thomas lost his fork down his shirt.

130 Ludwig Dr.
Fairview Heights,
IL
US

Bathed in smoky red and blue lighting like the jazz clubs of yore, Cupids Steakhouse literally glows with a purple, royal elegance. The grand piano, surrounded by a low wall of blue-lit glass blocks, waits stoically for the touch of a performer, while the sharply dressed wait staff hustle around it. They cater fine steaks and seafood from kitchen to table, followed by the wafting aromas of filet mignon, New Zealand lamb chops, and buttery king crab legs.

5225 N Illinois St
Fairview Heights,
IL
US

With a welcoming atmosphere and a bountiful menu of hearty tavern fare, Madison's Cafe fills its guests with succulent pastas, grilled steaks, daily specials, and more. Chow down on lunchtime sandwiches such as the Missouri club, a mélange of ham, turkey, bacon, provel cheese, tomato, and lettuce bookended by toasted sourdough ($8.49). Tongues can arrange an impromptu meet-and-greet with the beef vernaise, a genteel portion of filet mignon sporting a tasteful chapeau of gulf shrimp and white wine sauce ($25.99). To fend off post-entree depression, diners are invited to revel in the welcoming tavernous maw of the bar for a digestif or polish off a satisfying meal with a sweet cheese strudel ($4.99) or scoop of spumoni ($2.99).

2974 Highway K
O'Fallon,
MO
US