Italian Restaurants in Old Town

Select Local Merchants

Silver Grill Cafe was featured in Examiner.com and reviewed in Feasting Fort Collins. Yelpers give it a 3.5-star average. TripAdvisors give it four stars.

218 Walnut St
Fort Collins,
CO
US

Ingredient restaurant offers a smorgasbord of gourmet and customizable culinary bites in a quick-serve atmosphere, catering to dietary restrictions whenever possible. Local ingredients claim squatter's rights on the menu, sprucing up dishes such as the custom salads ($8.95), with more than 75 options to arrange into fully functioning veggie ecosystems.

101 S College Ave
Fort Collins,
CO
US

Plenty of college students study business. They study business, though, they don't start one of their own. UW students Jason and Rob, however, didn't sit around waiting for graduation. In the middle of an early 1990s night, they surveyed the phone book and agreed that they were tired of the sub-par pizza available to them. Boldly, they started making pies of their own. No business plan. No product testing. Jason and Rob took their pizza to the people, and a business was born.

Today, they're out of college and their Falbo Bros Pizzeria serves its inventive twists on New York-style thin crust, Chicago-style deep dish, and stuffed pizzas in 13 locations across three states. Fresh batches of hand-rolled dough don gourmet toppings such as giardiniera, artichoke hearts, and meatballs. The Falbo kitchens toss specialty pizzas such as the Zeus, whose black olives, spinach, feta cheese, and pepperoncini are baked with the heat of a lightning bolt. Chefs also bake meatball subs and top salads of artichoke hearts, roasted peppers, and grilled chicken with piquant blue cheese dressing. At Falbo's Fort Collins outpost, taps pour local beers from New Belgium and Odell in a seasonal beer garden, and cans of soda offer an alternative fizzy refreshment.

822 S College Ave
Fort Collins,
CO
US

Under the supervision of an experienced chef at Woody?s Tavern, crackling logs not only give pizza dough a crispy crunch, but also create complex, smoky flavors. Chefs top pizzas with specialty combinations, such as the California Dream's basil pesto and artichoke hearts or the Pep Pep Pepperoni's roasted poblanos and jalape?os, and use gluten-free crusts and big, round carrots for those with dietary restrictions. Customers can enjoy the slices by the pie or sample a variety at the shop?s featured all-you-can-eat salad, soup, and pizza bar. These dishes and their hearty half-pound burgers pair well with the 16 drafts on tap, award-winning wine, margaritas, and other cocktails from the bar.

518 West Laurel Street
Fort Collins,
CO
US

Marco's Pizza founder Pasquale "Pat" Giammarco began helping out at his family’s pizzeria when he was just a boy. The eatery provided a taste of home to the Gianmarco clan, who moved to the United States from Italy when Pat was 9 years old. Together with his father, young Pat learned the secrets to creating exceptional pizza sauce: three different types of vine-ripened tomatoes and spices that can only be imported from Italy or the moon.

The perfected sauce recipe continues to guide Pat’s kitchen operations, although these days he has considerably more help. Marco's Pizza has 350 locations in more than half the states as well as in the Bahamas, each store tossing fresh pizza dough daily before sprinkling on a trio of fresh cheeses.

1630 S Lemay Ave
Fort Collins,
CO
US

The kitchen admirals at the locally-owned Krazy Karl's Pizza assemble a menu of savory pies constructed from daily kneaded dough and fresh ingredients, all enhanced by sudsy brews from New Belgium. Catch a specialty dough disk ($6.49–$10.99), such as the Border, cloaked in green chilis, jalapeños, pepperoni, and Cajun seasoning. Diners can also ask a team of hardhat-wearing Lilliputians to construct their own pie ($3.99–$6.99 per pizza; $0.50–$1.50 for each additional topping) from 20 toppings, including feta, meatballs, and cream cheese. The Pub grinder ($5.99) arrives swollen with thinly sliced rib-eye beef, bacon, and cheddar. The kitchensmiths round out the menu with seven garden fresh salads ($3.75–$4.99) and juicy rotisserie wings ($4.99 for six large wings) that perform barrel rolls in the air after bathing in savory sauces.

1124 W Elizabeth St
Fort Collins,
CO
US