Italian Restaurants in Gilroy

Select Local Merchants

The Dutchman's Pizza & Pasta staff hand-rolls dough, stirs pots of their signature pizza sauce, and tops pies with locally harvested veggies. They have stuck with this tradition for more than three decades. In addition to baking nine pre-fabricated premium pizzas, they use their collected culinary wisdom to line sandwiches with housemade meatballs, deli cuts, and other parts of secret recipes passed down from the Fabulous Feasts branch of the Illuminati. Beyond pies and sandwiches, the team initiates guests into the Dutchman's Pizza & Pasta traditions by welcoming them to drink pitchers of beer, play a round on an arcade game, and watch sporting events.

6940 Chestnut St.
Gilroy,
CA
US

Picture in your mind a buffet. You're probably not thinking of locally grown vegetables and homemade soups, but that's exactly what you'll find at Fresh Choice. The restaurant essentially redefines what a buffet can be, filling tray after tray with organic produce and made-from-scratch entrées. Much of what you'll find is culled from Fresh Choice's very own 100+ acre farm, whose owners pride themselves on growing sustainable vegetables and crunchy salad crutons.

8697 San Ysidro Ave
Gilroy,
CA
US

Straw Hat's intricately interwoven history began with a crispy California crust, light sauce, secret six-cheese blend, and the dream of pizza for all. Today, a team of expert dough slingers spin out a slew of cheesy disks atop their dexterous digits and make that dream a reality, except for the part where you're naked at your old high school for some reason. Zealous pizzavores can drop in for a 15-inch six-cheese version or create a one-topping model by choosing from 25 different garnishes, including linguica, chorizo, and more. Walls of blithesome memorabilia, an arcade, and big-screen televisions constitute a fun environment where families and friends can chow down while catching up.

2026 Freedom Blvd
Freedom,
CA
US

Starting out at one spot in 1979, the Pizza factory has since expanded to five states, baking up their reputable pies in more than 110 locations. In the kitchen at each restaurant, cooks roll out their own pizza dough from scratch daily, topping it with 100% mozzarella cheese, premium meats, and fresh local vegetables. In addition to customizable pies, they build eight gourmet pizzas, such as the spinach and garlic, and the greek, which sports green bell peppers, red onions, black olives, and crumbled feta cheese. They also prepare calzones, pastas, and seven “awesome” sub sandwiches with oven-roasted rolls, slices of provolone cheese, and tiny periscopes.

301 The Alameda
San Juan Bautista,
CA
US