Italian Restaurants in Grove City

Select Local Merchants

Purveying pizzas and subs is a family affair for the friendly staffers at Flyers, who have been offering patrons saucy circulars and savory sandwiches since 1976. Like the devastating barrage of cake and ice cream that the Air Force drops on other countries during their birthday, The Bomber signature pizza bombards unsuspecting tasters with palatable flavors, particularly its combination of provolone cheese, mushroom, green peppers, and a gathering of meats ($7.99 for stromboli, $13.99 for 11"; $17.49 for 13"; $19.99 for 15"). Peruse pizza and sandwich options here.

5634 Hall Rd
Galloway,
OH
US

The mozzarella-mongers at Grandstand Pizza hand-toss and stone-bake piping-hot pizza pies and hand-pack 16 tongue-tantalizing subs. Mouths can catch a deluxe dough disk lavished in pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, and onions ($8.65+), or demolish a Chicago-style deep dish, oozing with layers of gooey mozzarella and accented with bite-size portraits of the Daley family ($7.95+). The Grandslam sub's crusty bun embraces five meats, three cheeses, and two vegetables ($6.25), and the vegi pleases meat-abstaining palates with a garden's worth of vegetables watered in creamy Italian dressing ($4.95). A panoply of desserts, including warm brownie bites ($3.75), induces smiles better than an upside-down giraffe.

4034 Broadway
Grove City,
OH
US

Joseppi's award-winning pies cover the Columbus region like plentiful toppings and melted provolone cover a pizza. Introduce teeth and tongue to The Topper, a house specialty loaded with little pepperonis, provolone, and grated cheeses ($12.99 for a 13"). The Joseppi's Favorite is topped with fresh, house-made italian sausage, cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, and peppers ($13.49 for a 13"), while The Veggie floods flat disks with the earth's crunchy bounty ($13.49 for a 13"). In addition to plentiful pies, a wealth of subs and salads awaits those wishing to diversify their edible geometry. Today's Groupon is valid for dine-in, carryout, or delivery, ensuring flavorful fare is provided for any family dinner or car-based food fight.

4062 Hoover Rd
Grove City,
OH
US

Pizza Pan appeases appetites with an assortment of carefully crafted pies and a wide-ranging menu of casual palate-pleasers. The restaurant’s pizza dough is fashioned fresh daily before being slung into disk form by expert pizzatologists and slathered in delectable sauce made the same morning. The squad of pie producers blends real mozzarella and provolone cheese, melting it on top of each savory circle to create a toothsome dairy shield that protects the priceless tomatoes underneath. Top-quality Hormel meats and fresh-cut vegetables mingle merrily atop the flavor frisbees, which come in sizes ranging from the six-slice small ($10.99, $1.75 per topping) to the gargantuan, 16-slice half-sheet pizza ($22.99, $3.75 per toping). Eaters can sate their need to chew on things other than pizza with ribs ($28.99 per slab), hoagies ($4.99), and chicken wings ($6.99 for 10) slathered in one of eight sauces.

1286 S High St
Columbus,
OH
US

Every morning, Tim Moretti makes the mighty marinara and fresh pasta that keep Moretti’s of Arlington patrons hooked. A beloved Columbus institution, Moretti's sports a menu of traditional favorites and modern classics such as braised meatballs, handcrafted ravioli, and stone-oven-baked pizza piled high with gourmet bites of brussels sprouts and goat cheese. The spacious interior of Moretti’s abuts an equally expansive warm-weather outdoor patio.

2124 Tremont Ctr
Upper Arlington,
OH
US

Cibo's chefs curate a sophisticated menu, artistically reimagining traditional Italian flavors in bold, contemporary recipes. Chefs layer sliced tomatoes with thick-cut medallions of mozzarella in each eye-catching caprese salad ($8), tucking basil between layers before sending basil oil and balsamic vinegar waltzing across the top. House-made gnocchi plays a cunning cupid to match the flavors of beef braciole with a coy tomato ragu ($16), and marinated, wood-grilled lamb chops hospitably host a dried-fruit mostarda ($28). Servers uncork bottles from Cibo's stockpile of dozens of red, white, and sparkling wines. Guests can also sip on a solo glass, such as the Franciscan chardonnay, powerfully fragranced with apple, pear, and honey, coming to a creamy decrescendo with notes of vanilla ($10).

4740 Reed Rd
Columbus,
OH
US