Bakeries in Hilton Head Island

Select Local Merchants

Peaks of frosting crown the cupcakes at Ronnie’s Bakery, which are ornamented with creative designs such as red-seamed baseballs or the faces of pop-culture icons. Larger cakes can be created to accompany handheld desserts.

850 William Hilton Pkwy
Hilton Head Island,
SC
US

Besides being islands, of course, Hilton Head Island and Manhattan have one crucial thing in common: they're both home to authentic, New York-style bagels.?At Island Bagel & Deli,?the cooks do things the Big Apple way, whipping up 16 varieties of bagels each day from scratch, then boiling them in a kettle of purified water.?Bagel flavors include chocolate chip, sesame, and cinnamon raisin, and, to make them even more enticing, the kitchen also crafts 12 flavors of cream cheese in-house, so customers don't have to go home and churn their own. Of course, bagels are just the beginning. Here, hungry guests will also a selection of signature sandwiches served on hoagies (or bagels), including the aptly named "Our Favorite," which features hot pulled turkey and bacon topped with provolone and cream cheese.

841 William Hilton Parkway
Hilton Head Island,
SC
US

Frosty's Italian Ices & More satisfies sweet cravings with a bounty of handmade italian ice, ice cream, and fudge. Frosty's cheerful exterior includes large windows, which allow guests to peek at the shop's sugary treats. Once inside, diners can nibble on hunks of creamy milk-chocolate fudge with almonds or fill bowls with glistening blueberry, pineapple, or strawberry italian ice.

71 Lighthouse Rd
Hilton Head Island,
SC
US

The devoted bakers at each Cookies by Design location bury their knuckles in soft dough and sweet frosting to craft top-notch treats for all manner of occasions. Whether customers are prepping for a birthday, a time to give thanks, or beekeeper appreciation day, Cookies by Design will cater to their sentiment-slinging needs by customizing a colorful bouquet or another edible display. Individually decorated cookies start at $7.50 each, and birthday baskets start at $15.99. The NCAA survival kit ($39.99+) makes a perfect gift for a spirited college freshman and offers a singular opportunity to literally eat the opposing team for breakfast. Orders should be placed at least 24 hours in advance so that cookie seeds have ample time to soak up milk and sprout into full-grown desserts.

108 Buckwalter Pkwy
Bluffton,
SC
US