Steakhouses in Indianapolis

Select Local Merchants

While St. Nick is out delivering toys, St. Elmo is delivering satisfying steak to delightful diners. The St. Elmo Steak House has had its claim in downtown Indianapolis since 1902. Over the years, the décor has changed a bit and the menu has grown, but guests will still find historical roots throughout the building. Guests will enjoy the award-winning wine cellar and options for private parties with several rooms available. The specialty here is no secret. Filet Mignon and Porterhouse Steak are served with such abundant and juicy flavors that are sure to keep diners returning for more. The King Crab and Shrimp Linguine delights the palette while the Crème Brulee massages the taste buds. St. Elmo’s is committed to supporting local farmers and is pleased to offer locally grown/produced products as part of their signature dishes. When your meal is finished, take home a taste of St. Elmo’s by purchasing the St. Elmo Steak House Cocktail Sauce or a gift card for a friend. Though open seven nights a week with valet parking and takeout options, be sure to make a reservation if you plan on dining in at this landmark restaurant.

127 S Illinois St
Indianapolis,
IN
US

Harry and Izzy's offers delicious and fresh American cuisine in an upscale location in Indianapolis, and has quickly become one of the most popular American restaurants in the Midwest. The restaurant is known for being a top steakhouse and for its ambiance and comfortable elegant dining setting. Although it has the look and feel of a Michelin starred restaurant the food is available at more than reasonable prices and there are always specials available for the many entrees and appetizers available. Some of the most popular options include the shrimp cocktail, prime rib sandwich (very popular), calamari, filet of salmon, several steak options, and several salad and dessert options. You can't go wrong stopping in for a quick lunch or a group dinner at Harry and Izzy's and most customers give the restaurant rave reviews for its fresh and delicious food and great service.

153 South Illinois Street
Indianapolis,
IN
US

As the only restaurant in downtown Indianapolis with a large, wall-mounted grill strategically positioned near its entrance, Weber Grill glorifies the art of flame-licked cooking through a menu that appropriately features grilled pizzas, steaks, burgers, barbecue and fish. For the more health-conscious set, a variety of soups, salads and a simple side items are available as well. Wood paneling and dark-colored tables and chairs help create a warm environment at the Weber Grill, which is located at the corner of Washington Street and Illinois Street. When the weather is appropriate, street-side patio meals are an option, though the restaurant’s sectioned yet spacious interior allows for both intimate dining and large-group gatherings. Children’s menu items and gluten-free selections are also available.

10 N Illinois St
Indianapolis,
IN
US

The bartenders at Brewstone Beer Company have trouble picking their favorite types of beer, so they don’t bother. Instead, they serve domestic and imported pours from all over the atlas, grabbing brews from as close as Sun King Brewing and as far away as the great ale houses of Europe. Each flavorful beer harmonizes with hearty steaks such as ribeyes, new york strips, and sirloins. They also play well with the menu’s half-pound Angus burgers topped with avocado mayo, seared ahi tuna spiced with wasabi mousse, and pasta tossed with spicy chicken and grape tomatoes. Feasts unfold inside a spacious dining room, where a mural of electric guitars presides over roomy leather booths and flat-screen televisions tuned to the day’s sports.

3720 East 82nd Street
Indianapolis,
IN
US

For a taste of the Lone Star State without leaving Indianapolis, this roadhouse has you covered. Start your meal with an order of deliciously deep-fried pickles served with a Cajun horseradish sauce, or try the Rattlesnake Bites (diced jalapenos and jack cheese, battered and fried) for a spicy kick. Next, an order of the Fall-Off-The-Bone ribs, which are slow cooked and slathered in a signature BBQ sauce, are a tender and flavorful option for any palate. Don’t forget about the steaks! The Fort Worth Ribeye is the house specialty, and it’s available in a variety of sizes. The full bar is always full of great options and specials if you’d like a drink.

9111 Michigan Rd
Indianapolis,
IN
US

The ’72 Dolphins aren’t the only winning combination produced by Coach Don Shula. Located below the Westin Hotel, the décor is elegant and simple, but nods to the namesake’s extensive football legacy can be seen throughout the dining experience. Try The Shula Cut, which is a center cut of premium Black Angus beef, aged to perfection and available in a variety of sizes to perfectly match your appetite. If you’d prefer seafood, the Daily Market Fish is cooked to order with your choice of four delicious sauces. The bar is full and the drink selection is extensive, so you’ll have no problem complementing your meal with the perfect refreshment.

50 S Capitol Ave
Indianapolis,
IN
US