Pizza in Kenmore

Select Local Merchants

When the chefs at John's Pizza & Subs’ approach batches of pizza dough, they channel the restaurant's three decades of expertise. Across the shop's four locations, specialty pies such as the Bob's Big Mac, whose combination of hamburger, thousand island dressing, and pickles is lauded by the Buffalo Pizza Fest, join made-to-order pizzas crowned with anchovies, hot peppers, pineapple, and other toppings. John's Pizza & Subs’ is also known for its original chicken-finger sub, as well as other hot and cold subs with unusual names, such as the rib eye and italian sausage Nightmare and the ham-and-turkey Hercules, whose more than 5 ounces of meat can sate each of a hydra's heads. Tacos, wraps, and wings help to round out the hearty menu.

1436 Niagara Falls Blvd
Tonawanda,
NY
US

It should come as no surprise that pizza is a specialty at JUST PIZZA & Wing Co. The restaurant's cooks infuse specialty crusts with sesame seeds, lemon pepper, and other seasonings, pile on fresh cheese and toppings such as sirloin steak and tiger shrimp, and even bake whole-wheat and gluten-free pies. But contrary to its name, JUST PIZZA & Wing Co.'s menu doesn't end there—non-doughy options include chicken wings in a variety of sauces. Patrons can even explore possible wine pairings on JUST PIZZA & Wing Co.'s website.

151 Division St.
North Tonawanda,
NY
US

More than 20 gourmet pizzas and 70 subs circulate the extensive menu at The Original Buffalo Pizzeria & Sub Shop. Pizza defends its title as most versatile foodstuff with a roster of specialty and customizable pies ($5.95–$35.95), including the Original Buffalo Deluxe pizza ($15.95 for small), which bears a scout sash brimming with edible badges, including pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, peppers, olives, and onion. Pie professionals infuse crusts with a host of flavors such as sesame seed, romano, or Cajun and sculpt dough to New York–style, Sicilian, stromboli, or gluten-free perfection. On the sub side of the menu, the roast beef relaxes in a flavor-fomenting sauna for nearly 10 hours to produce the roast-beef classic, a savory sub served on a garlic roll topped with fried mushrooms ($8.25 whole). A flock of regular or boneless wings soar in a sapid list of sauces, such as medium, mild, suicidal, hot barbecue, honey mustard, and italian ($9.25).

502 Elmwood Avenue
Buffalo,
NY
US

The disk artisans at Bocce Club Pizza make their pizzas from scratch daily using hand-stretched dough, a selection of 30 toppings, 100% whole-milk mozzarella, and sauce recipes that have been crafted into tasty combinations since 1946. Chunks of pineapple and canadian bacon surf mozzarella waves on the Hawaiian specialty pizza ($16.59), and steak and sautéed peppers make snow angels in a garlic spread on the steak white pizza ($18.59). All of the menu’s dough saucers boast a hearty whole-wheat doppelganger available upon request, and gluten-sensitive customers can play matchmaker between their single stomachs and a gluten-free quarter pie. To raise the edible altitude, Bocce Club Pizza also features un-flat fare such as the chicken fajita sub ($7.99) and a basket of 10 buffalo wings ($7.99), which—like romance novels—can be made hot, medium, mild, or Victorian.

4174 Bailey Ave
Buffalo,
NY
US

The chefs at Great Northern Pizza Kitchen draw upon Italian, Greek, and American culinary traditions while topping pizzas. After tossing crusts by hand, they turn to blue cheese, buffalo sauce, shredded pork, morsels of feta, and pico de gallo. Though some toppings seem adventurous, the mac 'n' cheese pizza and the potato-skin pie, a combination of bacon, sliced potatoes, and cheddar cheese, call to mind simple comfort foods. Tables clatter with plates of salads, pastas, and sandwiches in an 80-seat dining room with exactly enough spots for the 10 families cloned from the Brady Bunch.

5759 Main St
Williamsville,
NY
US

Gino & Joe's supplies quick workday lunches and leisurely family dinners alike with barbecue chicken pizzas, hot subs, and Italian food. In the kitchen, pizza specialists hurl discs of dough into the air before topping them with mouthwatering tomatoes or sausage, while cooks nearby assemble subs with thin-sliced capicola or bundle together veggie wraps. Pasta sauces are made fresh each day from imported tomatoes before they coat trays of savory meatballs or dinners of cheesy baked ziti.

400 Main St
Buffalo,
NY
US