BBQ Restaurants in Lancaster

Select Local Merchants

Here's the thing about Famous Dave: he wasn't always famous. Dave Anderson inherited his passion for barbecue from his father, a humble construction worker who knew where to find the best barbecue on Chicago's street corners. In 1994, Dave opened his first barbecue shack in Hayward, Wisconsin, and before long, the shack was attracting 5,000 customers weekly?a momentous feat considering Hayward had a population of 1,800. Dave's lifelong pursuit of barbecue perfection had certainly paid off. It gave him a new life's work to be proud of. And, of course, a new first name to put on his passport.

With locations now spread across the U.S., Canada, and even Puerto Rico, Famous Dave's has become a revelation for barbecue fans. It has earned more than 700 awards, including first-place honors for its ribs, wings, and sauces. Most of these awards have Famous Dave's cooking process to thank. For every batch, pitmasters hand-rub high-quality cuts and cook them for hours at a time in live-wood smokers, taking care to not disturb the dragons napping between the logs. For Famous Dave's renowned ribs, the process has an extra step after the smoker, as each rack gets tossed on a grill to caramelize the sauces before serving.

1753 Walden Ave.
Buffalo,
NY
US

WIVB featured Blue Buffalo on Good News in Buffalo. Blue Buffalo's inventive twist on southern food has caught the attention of the Buffalo News and Buffalo Rising.

454 Pearl Street
Buffalo,
NY
US

Bill and Amy Wesolowski were no strangers to barbecue when they opened their restaurant. After all, they'd been grilling up mountainous platters of ribs, pulled pork, and grilled chicken at local parties and special events since 2008. Within their cheerful, sunlit joint, the seasoned caterers and skilled barbecue chefs whip up their signature dishes, along with southern-style sides of barbecue beans, collard greens, and coleslaw. The duo even accommodates vegetarians with meat-free menu selections, unlike other barbecue venues that require vegetarians to wear an itchy wreath of string beans around their necks. Plates pair with bottles of beer as they sit atop the white-cloth tables of the casual dining room, where colorful photographs and drawings of jazz instruments adorn the walls.

1260 Hertel Avenue
Buffalo,
NY
US

What started as a single corner pizza shop has expanded into a dozen Just Pizza outposts that dish out over 75 varieties of pizzas. Offerings include innovative combos such as the chicken club with bacon and Virginia ham and the shrimp scampi with sweet peppers. Even classic recipes get a twist from surprising toppings. For example, the Hawaiian delights those expecting just ham and pineapple with maraschino cherries and sliced almonds. The rest of the menu features a smattering of subs and salads, as well as chicken wings glazed with interesting sauces such as blackberry bbq and spicy orange. And for the sophisticated palate, Just Pizza even offers a page on their website with suggestions for what wine and what formal bib goes best with each of their styles of pizza.

5380 Genesee St
Bowmansville,
NY
US

Matt Dombrowski opened Magruders more than 22 years ago, and ever since, it’s been serving the public’s need for hearty pub food and drinks. The menu of crispy apps, build-your-own-burgers, and sauced-up buffalo wings complements pours from the bar, which diners can enjoy inside or out on the patio amid fresh air and attention-seeking trees. At the end of each week, the pub entertains guests with comedy, music, or drink promotions.

4995 Broadway
Depew,
NY
US

Equipped with plenty of televisions and a menu of palate-pleasing favorites, Buffalo Sports Garden provides fans with a superb viewing environment for games big and small. Kick things off with banana peppers stuffed with three-cheese filling ($7.99), or choose from among four different specialty jumbo wings ($9.99 for 10, $13.99 for 20). Custom-built burgers (starting at $8.49) allow protein Picassos to decorate sirloin canvases with a palette of different cheeses and toppings, and a plain personal pizza ($4.99) allows cheese Caravaggios to paint with toppings such as bacon and mushrooms ($1.00 each). Herbivores can graze on grilled veggie pasta, an amalgamation of red bell peppers, zucchini, yellow squash, carrots, and broccoli ($7.50).

2945 Southwestern Blvd
Orchard Park,
NY
US