Italian Restaurants in Middletown

Select Local Merchants

A smattering of meats, veggies, and cheeses adorn pizza crusts inside Tre Colore Pizzeria & Ristorante. Chefs also whip up classic Italian dishes such as chicken parmesan, penne with vodka sauce, cheesy calzones, and a variety of barbecue dishes including pulled pork, pulled chicken, 1/4 or 1/2 or whole chickens, beef brisket, and sausage. The eatery delivers orders to customers? homes for optimal convenience, and it houses a private room that holds up to 40 party guests or three velociraptors.

1207 State Route 35
Middletown,
NJ
US

Each morning, TJ’s Pizza’s chefs craft mounds of pizza dough from scratch. They stretch out crusts into rounds or squares sprinkled with classic toppings or premium ingredients like balsamic chicken, sun dried tomatoes, ranch dressing, and chipotle sauce. In addition to pies, the dough forms calzone pockets, which are then deep-fried. The pizzeria also serves oven-baked sandwiches and baked pasta dishes.

18 Marshall Hill Road
West Milford,
NJ
US

Retired New York City firefighters and longtime Warwick residents Joe Boccia, Mike Darcey, and Jim Kelly have developed a brotherly bond. So when they decided to open their own restaurant, it was only fitting that they chose to name it ?Fratello,? which means brother in Italian. The menu at this cozy restaurant and bar is packed with traditional Italian favorites as well as regional specialties. Chef Larry Klein uses imported pastas and homemade sauces to craft dishes such as Italian-style pot roast and jumbo cheese ravioli. In addition to being available in individual portions, all entrees can be served family style, a traditional Italian way of eating that encourages sharing and sparring with ladles.

Pizza chef Nicola Lombardo brings 30 years of experience to preparing a mouth-watering assortment of homemade pies from the eatery?s brick oven. Opt for an old-fashioned, Sicilian-style thin-crust pizza or seasonal specialty such as the fresh pear and gorgonzola pie.

22 Spring St
Warwick,
NY
US

The chefs at Little Anthony's Pizza populate a menu (click "menu selection" on the sidebar) of Italian cuisine with fresh grilled burgers and sauce-smothered pastas. Like Olympic swimmers during times of drought, appetizing shrimps swim laps in cocktail sauce in preparation for the main event. Among the many main course offerings, diners can sink fangs into the succulent veal saltimbocca or chicken parmigiana, soaking in the quiet calm of Little Anthony's unassuming dining space marked by white tablecloths, framed artwork, and potted plants.

530 County Route 515
Vernon,
NJ
US

Silvio?s Italian Villa is located inside a restored Revolutionary War?era mansion, where a series of crimes that took place in the 1970s are said to have filled the home with ghostly chills, mysterious sounds, and other paranormal activity ever since. Instead of trying to distance itself from the home's past, the restaurant has embraced it?it was even recently featured on Syfy?s Haunted Collector. Depending on the night, guests might see doors open on their own or "Do You Want to Split Dessert" scrawled in ghostly handwriting on their napkin, but they'll always have their choice from a plentiful Italian menu that includes gourmet entrees such as lobster, rack of lamb, and filet mignon topped with shrimp and gorgonzola. Traditional Italian favorites are available, too, including bruschetta pizza, chicken parmigiana, and house-made ravioli.

274 Rte. 94 S
Warwick,
NY
US

Since its humble beginnings in 1994 on San Francisco's Fillmore Street, Extreme Pizza has been committed to innovation, topping house-baked crusts with unorthodox toppings such as hummus, mandarin oranges, black bean, or barbecue pork. At locations in 11 different states, Extreme Pizza allows customers to call their orders ahead through smartphone, desktop computer, or semaphore, arriving to dine in-store or pick-up. Take-and-bake pies come crowned with toppings including Portuguese linguica, roasted red peppers, or creamy fontina cheese. A wealth of alternatives populate the menu, from gluten-free pizza options to crisp salads, golden-brown calzones, and meaty subs.

218 County Road 519
Sussex,
NJ
US