Pizza in Upper East Side

$11 for Italian Food at Joey Buona’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

Joey Buona's

Juneau Town

$20 $11

(59)

Italian eatery serves up family-style dishes such as oven-baked rigatoni, baked lasagna, and traditional thin-crust style pizza

45% Off Pizza and Bar Food at Happy Tap

Happy Tap

West Allis

$20 $11

Neighborhood bar serves thin-crust pizza and garlic, cheesy, and pizza bread while games play on flat-screen televisions in the background

Up to 50% Off Pizza at Tarantino

Tarantino

Fairview

$31 $16

Shrimp and black olive specialty pizza highlights a menu of pizzas, pasta, hot sandwiches, and appetizers

43% Off Thin Crust Pizza Meal from Pizzeria Scotty

Pizzeria Scotty

West View

$19.18 $11

Carryout or delivery thin crust pizzas served with deep-fried garlic bread sticks and soda

Up to 60% Off at Michaleno's Pizzeria

Michaleno's Pizzeria

Inside Paradise Plaza

$20 $10

Family run pizzeria makes double-crust stuffed pizzas and specialty pies, such as gyro pizza, along with wings and fried fish buckets

Nick-N-Willy's Pizza – 50% Off

Nick-N-Willy's Pizza

River Crossing

$24 $12

Classic pizza combinations abound, but there's also Greek-influenced feta-topped Aegean, Canadian Chicken Club, and barbecue-chicken variety

Up to 54% Off at Rocky's Pizzeria

Rocky's Pizzeria

Lindenhurst

$21.72 $10

Bite into your choice of three appetizers, such as chicken fingers, tater tots, and fried shrimp, plus handmade cheese pizzas

Papa John's – Up to 55% Off Pizza 

Papa John's

Multiple Locations

$26 $12

Hand-tossed thin- or original-crust pizzas with thick cloaks of sauce made from California-grown tomatoes

35% Off Pizza Delivery or Takeout at Mike's Pizza

Mike's Pizza

Gages Lake

$10 $6.50

Create your own deep dish or hand tossed pizza from 15 toppings, 3 crust flavors, and sauces such as alfredo or barbecue

Up to 49% Off at Mancino's Pizza & Grinders

Mancino's Pizza & Grinders

Multiple Locations

$21.48 $11

(72)

Sandwiches from meatball subs to Cuban grinders; pizzas decorated with gyro meat, feta, and other adventurous toppings

40% Off Pizza Package at Jet's Pizza

Jet's Pizza in Wheeling

Wheeling

$29.93 $18

(42)

Crispy crust & gooey cheese ferry fresh toppings into stomachs on five-topping 8 Corner Pizza accompanied by an order of Deep Dish Bread

48% Off Pizza at Lou's Pizza Factory

Lou's Pizza Factory

Arlington Heights

$32.45 $17

Pizza topped with the topping of your choice such as green pepper or sausage; mozzarella sticks, breaded eggplant, and onion ring appetizers

36% Off at Wayne's Pizza

Wayne's Pizza

Arlington Heights

$25 $16

(26)

Since 1964, Wayne's has used secret family recipes and fresh ingredients to craft high-quality pizzas, pasta, and classic Italian dishes

45% Off Pizza and Burgers at CravePizza

CravePizza

Mount Prospect

$20 $11

(37)

Wings dressed in five types of sauce ready appetites for thin-, pan-, or stuffed-crust pizzas, chicken caesar salad & bacon-topped burgers

Up to 43% Off Italian Food at Father & Son Italian Kitchen

Father & Son Italian Kitchen

Skokie

$20 $12

Italian eatery in business 60+ years makes all items in-house; flatbread pizza, pan pizza, pastas, fresh salads and Abbe's gluten-free menu

Up to 47% Off at Dahmen's Pizza Place

Dahmen's Pizza Place

Madison

$25.45 $14

(115)

Guests dine on pizzas topped with basil, Italian sausage, mushrooms, and Canadian bacon, sided with draft beers and breadsticks

Select Local Merchants

Featured on OnMilwaukee.com during its early-aughts inception, Sala Da Pranzo's dinner and lunch menus offer both contemporary and traditional Italian fare to fill the boot-shaped hole in Milwaukee's collective heart. Dinner diners get the chance to taste the ricotta-enhanced grandeur of the house specialty appetizer, the eggplant con pane ($11). Pastas like the saporito ($18.50), which tosses shrimp, tomato, basil, and garlic into the capable hands of fettuccini pasta, are available all day, and scene-stealing entrees such as the grilled salmon ($26) with chive cream sauce or the tenderloin porto vino ($34) shine like a strobe light covered in smaller strobe lights. For afternoon eaters, the veggie balsamic sub ($7.25) staves off narcolepsy with the time-tested jolt of mozzarella, tomato, onion, cucumber, lettuce, and balsamic vinaigrette.

2613 E Hampshire Ave
Milwaukee,
WI
US

In the warm spirit of Italian-style cooking, VIA Downer comfort diners with a hearty selection of homemade pastas and pizzas, which were described as "beautifully crisp" by the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel. A parade of palate-popular dishes emerges from the restaurant’s open kitchen flaunting bowls of al dente fettuccine milano draped in a flavorful blanket of tangy goat cheese, sun-dried tomatoes, garlic, and fresh basil. VIA Downer's menu also accommodates special diets with plentiful gluten-free options, from smoked salmon crostini to gluten-free garlic pizzas topped with cheese and grilled portobello. Diners break bread within the restaurant’s cool, laid-back setting with brightly painted modern art and exposed brick walls strong enough to withstand huffs and puffs from a hungry pack of wolves.

2625 N Downer Ave
Milwaukee,
WI
US

It's got imaginative cocktails, gallons of craft and mainstream brews, and hearty comfort food, but The Hotch Spot is as much about what you do as what you eat and drink. Depending on the date, there might be a live band rocking out on the stage or a board-game day with a DJ. The bar's '80s and '90s nostalgia permeates everything from the special events to the scrunchie slingshots that land plates on tables.

And while the food's homestyle preparation may remind guests of family meals, modern touches such as organic ingredients and craft beers update the fare. Weekend brunches feature the signature Hotch Hash, full of entire refrigerators worth of mix-ins, from broccoli and artichokes to turkey and andouille sausage. At lunch and dinner, burgers, salads, and pizzas quell appetites. The bar pours drafts and cracks open brews from New Glarus, Angry Orchard, and Stella Artois, among others. Bartenders can also mix up a variety of drinks, including The BLT, a bloody mary with Guinness garnished with practically a side salad: bacon, lime, and tomato.

1813 E Kenilworth Pl
Milwaukee,
WI
US

Toppers' pizzasmiths craft a menu of saucy cylinders, sandwiches, and wings until 4 a.m. Swan dive into an inventive specialty pie, such as the cool chicken-bacon-ranch or the spinach-and-feta-speckled California Topper ($13.99 for a 12"), or construct your own pizza with more than 20 available toppings for an edible edifice more flavorsome than an astronaut's house of Tang ($9.99+ for a 12"). Other tongue merriments include buffalo wings ($5.99 for six), quesadillas ($7.99+), and grinder sandwiches, which come enswathing savory meats such as chipotle chicken or smoky barbecue beef ($5.99 for 6", $8.99 for 12"). Topperstix—hand-tossed breadsticks piggybacking tasty adornments that range from cheese to berry—can act as meal sidekicks, desserts, or handheld props during table-top reenactments of Don Juan's famous food fight against Duke de Lorca ($4.99+; eight dipping sauces available).

1093 East Kenilworth Place
Milwaukee,
WI
US

The doughsmiths at Salvatore's Pizzeria assemble a menu of five specialty pizzas and six sandwiches made with fresh ingredients and dough and bread crafted by Peter Sciortino's Bakery, a Milwaukee staple. Like Pavlov's dogs on their Sicilian vacation, mouths water instinctively when the scent of fresh-mozzarella-and-marinara appetizers ($5.95) fills the air. Medium Veggie Lovers pizzas ($15.65) round up a posse of pugnacious greens, olives, onions, and green peppers to coax bubbling cheese into settling amid Salvatore's famous crust, and a medium supreme pie ($17.10) ups the ante with sausage and pepperoni. Sandwiches such as the meatball sub ($6.95) accompany sides of fries and expertly transport saucy contents, illustrating why the best suitcases are usually constructed from bread.

2213 E Capitol Dr
Shorewood,
WI
US

Yelpers and Citysearchers alike give Pizza Shuttle a 3.5-star average. Seventy-eight percent of over 100 Urbanspooners recommend it:

1827 N Farwell Ave
Milwaukee,
WI
US