Cafes in Muncie

Select Local Merchants

Incredible Yogurt is independent and locally owned, letting its broad, rotating selection of flavors branch out into different territories. On any given day, flavors can range from chocolate caramel corn and peach to black raspberry and sugar-free blueberry cheesecake. The shop complements its frozen treats with sandwiches and warm soups.

3804 W Bethel Ave
Muncie,
IN
US

The ovens at Bowman Bakery, Inc., work almost as hard as the skilled bakers and pastry chef who churn out a full spread of from-scratch sweets. Their headlining dessert, the cheesecake, comes in close to 65 varieties, such as pumpkin pecan crunch, cherry jubilee, chocolate chip cookie dough, and marshmallow. The menu also includes fudge-filled cupcakes, cookies, turnovers, muffins, and 85 different donut flavors, which rotate regularly. Even the bread at Bowman—banana nut, blueberry, apple streusel—comes in sweet flavors.

48 S Perry St
Hagerstown,
IN
US

Inside a gleaming, recently remodeled storefront, a mosaic of glittering tiles surrounds Zogurts Frozen Yogurt?s self-service yogurt machines. Each machine contains an all-natural recipe of yogurt or sorbet, available in flavors that rotate often. All the yogurts and sorbets are fat free and contain no white table sugar, and the store always has options for diabetic and lactose-intolerant customers.

10134 Brooks School Rd
Fishers,
IN
US

The scent of fresh-baked sweets draws people into the boutique-style bakery, but it's the fluffy buttercream made fresh daily and piled high on each cupcake that keeps them sticking around for more. "People eat first with their eyes," says owner and baker Corrie Case, who uses the creativity she learned from her mother to construct aesthetically pleasing desserts. Baking since she was just 10 years old, Corrie always thought she would open her own candy shop, as everyone who tasted her cupcakes encouraged her to do so. Today, her bakery’s kitchen shines in robin’s-egg blue, her kitchen's creations neatly lined up inside glass cases as they tempt customers with their chic designs and fluffy textures. Coveted flavors include the Snickers cupcake, which melds the flavors of the favored candy bar and the Dreamy White, a french vanilla cupcake topped with clouds of vanilla frosting. Corrie’s coconut cream pie tempts with peaks of whipped cream, and her house-made caramel corn transports her back to the candy shops of her childhood with every batch she makes. Her baked goods pair well with gelato from Gelato Da Vinci, a local purveyor who whips up the cold treats from a generations-old recipe, or with coffee from local roaster Harvest Cafe. It seems Corrie has really found her calling. Says the baker, "I love that I get to wake up every day and make sweets that people love."

11009 Allisonville Rd
Fishers,
IN
US