Steakhouses in New Castle

Select Local Merchants

Locally owned and operated since 1999, Peterson's is renowned for our prime steaks, fresh seafood flown in daily, award winning wine list, outstanding service, and distinguished atmosphere. Come in and see for yourself!!

7690 E 96th St
Fishers,
IN
US

At Volcano Steak House and Sushi Bar, the chefs work culinary magic right at the tables. Hibachi dinners can include tasty combinations of steak and shrimp, chicken and scallops, or vegetarian options. Along with hibachi meals, the chefs also create raw or cooked sushi rolls at the sushi bar.

7255 Fishers Landing Dr.
Fishers,
IN
US

As the only restaurant in downtown Indianapolis with a large, wall-mounted grill strategically positioned near its entrance, Weber Grill glorifies the art of flame-licked cooking through a menu that appropriately features grilled pizzas, steaks, burgers, barbecue and fish. For the more health-conscious set, a variety of soups, salads and a simple side items are available as well. Wood paneling and dark-colored tables and chairs help create a warm environment at the Weber Grill, which is located at the corner of Washington Street and Illinois Street. When the weather is appropriate, street-side patio meals are an option, though the restaurant’s sectioned yet spacious interior allows for both intimate dining and large-group gatherings. Children’s menu items and gluten-free selections are also available.

10 N Illinois St
Indianapolis,
IN
US

The bartenders at Brewstone Beer Company have trouble picking their favorite types of beer, so they don’t bother. Instead, they serve domestic and imported pours from all over the atlas, grabbing brews from as close as Sun King Brewing and as far away as the great ale houses of Europe. Each flavorful beer harmonizes with hearty steaks such as ribeyes, new york strips, and sirloins. They also play well with the menu’s half-pound Angus burgers topped with avocado mayo, seared ahi tuna spiced with wasabi mousse, and pasta tossed with spicy chicken and grape tomatoes. Feasts unfold inside a spacious dining room, where a mural of electric guitars presides over roomy leather booths and flat-screen televisions tuned to the day’s sports.

3720 East 82nd Street
Indianapolis,
IN
US

The prime rib at The Library Restaurant & Pub gets slow-roasted for a minimum of 18 hours to ensure high quality and maximum tenderness. It's only right that the chefs take such care preparing meals, because the food has to match up to the restaurant's fine, elegant aesthetics. In the Mon Rêve room, for example, exquisite 18th- and 19th-century European oil paintings stand out against violet-blue walls. Even the bar area—where servers pour fine wines and cocktails—boasts sports-themed oil paintings, and outside, a fountain and rose garden carry on the building's original artistic design as a new-age French chateau.

2610 S Lynhurst Dr
Indianapolis,
IN
US

The pit master at World Bar-B-Que works hard slow-cooking Carolina-style pulled pork, Texas brisket, and St. Louis–style pork ribs, imbuing each meat with distinctive barbecue bark and deep, smoky flavors. After the cuts have smoked for 6–15 hours, diners take over with finishing touches, adorning their choice of meats with sauces such as sweet-and-spicy blackberry habanero and classic sides such as potato salad and baked beans. They can also forge everything from smoked and beer-soaked burgers to authentic Cuban sandwiches.

On certain nights, patrons can finish off meaty cuts and showcase their singing chops with open-mic and karaoke sessions. The generous eatery also sets aside one day a week for a "World Invasion"—a chance for local groups, charitable organizations, or extraterrestrial barbecue-reconnaissance parties to take over the restaurant and receive a portion of the evening's sales.

4029 N Main St
Dayton,
OH
US