Italian Restaurants in Newburgh

Select Local Merchants

Pastas, olive oils, and tomato sauces imported from Italy line the aisles of Noto's Italian Deli, giving shoppers all they need to prepare authentic Italian cuisine at home. But many patrons prefer to leave the food preparation to the cooks behind the deli counter. Starting at 6 a.m., those cooks fry eggs for breakfast sandwiches and omelets brimming with pastrami, homemade italian sausage, and other savory ingredients. Later in the day, the focus shifts to sandwiches piled with italian meats, housemade stuffed lasagna, homemade italian sausage, chicken marsala, and specials such as Black and Bleu philly cheesesteaks. Patrons quench their thirst with natural fruit juices and fresh fruit-flavored waters.

165 South Plank Road
Newburgh,
NY
US

Although it's the self-proclaimed oldest restaurant and bar in Poughkeepsie, The Derby hasn't had any trouble adapting to the modern age. Live musicians and DJs frequently fill the old-school pub with upbeat tunes, which resound throughout spacious dining rooms that collectively seat up 125 diners. Cooks whip up tasty pub bites, such as brick-oven flatbreads topped with chipotle-barbecue chicken and mac 'n' cheese chock-full of smoked bacon and Maine lobster. The Derby even accommodates gluten-free patrons with their very own menu, which include bacon-wrapped shrimp and breadless french onion soup.

96 Main Street
Poughkeepsie,
NY
US

Sal's soothes grumbling hunger tubs with its eclectic entourage of edibles, including pizza, specialty pies, calzones, seafood, and other Italian favorites. Anchor incisors on the buffalo-chicken pizza's mozzarella shores ($16/small, $18/large), or tune taste knobs to the egg-battered frequencies of the eggplant parmigiana, which dons a jaunty dressing of mozzarella cheese and marinara sauce ($13.50). Patrons of the noodled arts can commission a meal from Sal's pasta offerings, and garden grubbers can slip into some serious leafage with a bevy of salad selections.

1885 Route 6
Carmel,
NY
US

The dough halo hovers in the air, free-for a split second-from gravity's machinations. This airborne moment is short-lived, and the circlet plummets back into the hands of the New York Pizza Company chef, who repeats the up-and-down cycle until he deems the dough ready to be festooned with toppings. Masters of the well-made pie, New York Pizza Company's chefs pride themselves in their hand-tossed dough and the fresh toppings-such as ricotta, roma tomatoes, and barbecue chicken-that dapple their surfaces. Once a pizza has been assembled, the chefs slip it into the kitchen's brick oven where off-duty suns imbue it with a golden, toasty patina. Along with their signature pies, the chefs also whip up hot and cold subs, calzones, pastas, and soups.

3399 Crompond Rd
Yorktown Heights,
NY
US

Frankie & Augie'z tempts taste buds with its Italian pastas, soups, and seafood on the regular dining-room side, and makes mouths water with its array of bubbly, cheesy pizzas on the more casual pizzeria side. Plates of succulent broiled salmon, tender veal, and plump cheese-stuffed tortellini rest upon cloth-covered tables in the dining-room side. On the pizzeria side, traditional New York?style or brick-oven-style pizzas, which rebel against convention by wearing their sauce on top of their cheese layer and getting tattoos, top caf? tables sans cloths.

3673 Hill Boulevard
Jefferson Valley Yorktown,
NY
US

Like its log cabin location, Arturo's Tavern exudes the warmth of home by serving up an extensive selection of Italian dishes. Sauces from Bolognese to white clam, for instance, coat a choice of eight pastas, including cavatelli and whole-wheat linguini. Hearty mains like chicken scarpariello and veal parmigiana dominate dinner, while lunchtime features sandwiches such as open-faced grilled chicken with saut?ed escarole and mozzarella. House-made desserts and martinis in flavors such as caramel apple and Nutella end meals on sweet notes.

878 U.S. 6
Mahopac,
NY
US