Seafood Restaurants in Newmarket

Select Local Merchants

Inside the bustling St. Lawrence Market, Domenic’s Fish Market sprawls beneath a giant sign, its rows of fresh mussels, shrimp, and halibut tantalizing all who’ve frequented the spot since 1967. From behind clean, well-lit counters, the well-dressed staff offers up a wealth of items plucked from the sea, including live lobsters, Arctic char, whitefish, and their signature vodka-smoked salmon. They also arm customers with recipes and cooking advice, such as tips for serving a perfectly cooked filet of fish or perfectly balanced 6-foot tower of lobster.

93 Front St E
Toronto,
ON
CA

Executive Chef Chaz Bulera and his team fashion dinner and lunch menus out of selectively sizzled meats, fish, and pasta. Lunch fare, such as a pulled-pork sandwich ($8) and a buffalo-chicken wrap with its coif of blue cheese ($9) effortlessly shame standard sandwich-shop selections. The dinner menu kick-starts appetite engines with sesame-seared ahi tuna ($9) and subtly seasoned calamari ($7) before revving them lightly with a portobello-pesto sandwich ($8) or heavily with a bacon-wrapped filet mignon ($21).

971 E River Rd
Grand Island,
NY
US

Red Mill Inn’s rustic, two-story exterior engenders idyllic visions of a bygone era. Black clapboard shutters pop against the old farmhouse's bright red walls, which were built in 1858, and a giant wooden water mill nestles beside carefully trimmed hedges. Inside, dark wood floors and paneling surround wood tables, a roaring brick fireplace, and antique light fixtures. But this bucolic atmosphere belies a hectic kitchen staff who bustle to conjure flames beneath tender cuts of prime rib and filet mignon. Famous for their char-grilled steaks, fresh seafood, and Sunday brunch specials, Red Mill Inn also specializes in down-home country classics such as pan-fried calf's liver and Yankee pot roast. After dinner, house-made desserts arrive courtesy of an onsite pastry chef, whose creations shock sweet teeth more than a retainer lined with Pop Rocks.

8326 Main Street
Williamsville,
NY
US

Back in business after a fire in 2009, the Boston Hotel boasts a menu of USDA Choice steaks and prime rib, as well as sea scallops and lobster. The restaurant?s many fresh fish offerings get added attention on Fridays with specials that include a fresh haddock fish fry and linguini with fresh clam sauce. A selection of draft beers helps wash down entrees or enliven open-bar parties. Lunch hours are 10:30 a.m. to 3:30 p.m.

5555 Genesee St
Lancaster,
NY
US

In 1828, Reuben Burr sold his property to a family of wealthy carriage makers, the Cosfords, who christened their new home with the name Oakland Hall. More than 170 years and several owners, purposes, and names later, Tom and Irene Ntoulas transformed Burr's homestead into the Oakland Hall Inn, a fine-dining restaurant whose history complements its classic, upscale food. Chef Charyk plucks flavour and inspiration from the herb garden behind the inn, culls Ontario-sourced veggies and lamb, and brings in specialty cheeses, venison, quail, and perfect French pronunciation from Quebec. He aims to surprise his guests with flavours they've never tried, and more than 200 Old and New World wines ensure that each new experience is expertly paired with a delightful vintage.

16003 Yonge Street
Aurora,
ON
CA

Surrounded by the colors of the warm Italian sun, diners at Mamma Mia Trattoria feast on authentic wood-fired pizzas and sauce-slathered meats and pastas. Inside the cozy dining room, servers present plates of fresh spinach gnocchi, mushroom risotto, and veal-stuffed ravioli, pouring red and white wines into awaiting chalices for romantic dates and ceremonial pasta sacrifices. During lunch, chefs also line hot paninis with homemade meatballs or grilled Italian sausage.

17480 Yonge St
Newmarket,
ON
CA