Cafes in North Amityville

Select Local Merchants

As detailed in a segment on Restaurant Hunter on FiOS1, the plain bagel is Stuff A Bagel's best seller, though the everything bagel a close second. Following a recipe handed down to co-owners Phil and Lisa Cirrone, the bagels are boiled and baked without adding preservatives. Besides bagels, Cirrone's team assembles hearty breakfast sandwiches or makes sweet blueberry pancakes, and bagels also serve as the basis for sandwiches at lunchtime, piled high with tuna, cheese, roast beef, and more.

348 Broadway
Bethpage,
NY
US

Framed in arched woodwork, scenic murals of the Italian countryside line one wall of La Piazzetta Cafe and mirrors stand guard over teal banquettes on the other. Small bouquets of vibrant-hued flowers are eternally in bloom at the center of each table, weighed down with plated Italian favorites. Shrimp, veal, chicken, meatballs, and eggplant all receive the parmigiana treatment, and pasta dishes offer more than 20 varieties, including rigatoni montonara and dried macaroni for making crafts at the table. Guests can share a specialty pie such as the buffalo-chicken pizza, or horde their own 12-inch personal pizza. Diners can feast inside where a television entertains kids, relax at a bistro table outdoors, or order catered fare for their next Golden Girls viewing party.

542 Woodbury Rd
Plainview,
NY
US

South Bay Market seamlessly blends freshly made sandwiches, salads, and prepared foods with the ambiance and ingredients of an upscale eatery. The counter houses prepared entrees such as pasta salads, Dr Pepper–coated ribs, and panko-crusted chicken cutlets. Behind the counter, a chef prepares custom salads by peppering greens with walnuts, mushrooms, avocado, or bacon and nestles turkey, roast beef, and grilled eggplant into sandwiches or wraps. While their food is being prepared, customers can browse a selection of drinks including juice or soda and snacks such as premier pretzels, north fork chips, or Tate's chocolate chip cookies before heading over to café tables to eat and play travel Twister.

347 S Oyster Bay Rd
Plainview,
NY
US

Teapot takes its inspiration from the Victorian tearooms of old, where tea was equal parts an excuse to nosh mouthwatering sweets and a social engagement that eventually led to common-law marriages. Get into English character with a scone with butter or preserves ($4.50) to complement a hot, steaming pot of Earl Grey or Darjeeling ($6.95). Teapot's steepable leaf selection has more than 30 varieties of white, black, oolong, rooibos, herbal, and green goodness. While a bountiful brew dances upon your tongue, nibble bites of a specialty sandwich such as the Elizabeth, a cucumber and herb-cream sandwich on a toasted baguette, or the William—white cheddar, green apple, and herb mayonnaise on a croissant ($7.95 each). Pastries and salads are also on the menu.

2922 Merrick Rd
Bellmore,
NY
US

Bageltown Cafe, opened in February 2013, serves up coffee, tea, and classic deli cuisine. Patrons can order bagels smeared with scallion- or strawberry-infused cream cheeses, or opt for bialys and made-from-scratch baked sweets that are baked fresh each day. Cooks also grill panini sandwiches, prepare whitefish and lox salads, and sell Boar's Head meats and cheeses by the pound.

1363 Jerusalem Ave
Merrick,
NY
US

Indecisive appetites will be sated by the selection of breakfast, burgers, pasta, and more at Post Ave Cafe. Like putting a grocery-store conveyor belt in a pair of tights and sending it on a world-saving mission, the overstuffed hot heroes—including the potato and egg ($7.25) or the shrimp parmigiana ($8.95)—burst with a lineup of ingredients. The Greek burger sandwiches hunger with a 6-ounce beef patty topped by feta cheese and tomatoes on an English muffin with Greek salad, coleslaw, and pickles ($8.95). The pasta-with-seafood combination hooks a meal-worthy menagerie of mussels, clams, and shrimp splashed in a garlic-and-white-wine sauce, just like bringing seasoning to the local aquarium ($16.95). The meat averse can cut their teeth on a veggie whole-wheat wrap, stuffed with grilled broccoli, spinach, onions, mushrooms, and pesto sauce before leafing through a tossed salad ($8.95), and breakfast visitors are treated to Uncle Vinny's favorite omelette, an egg amalgamation of sausage, bacon, and American cheese flanked by a short stack of pancakes ($8.95).

173 Post Ave
Westbury,
NY
US