Italian Restaurants in Pataskala

Pizza Packages with Options for Soda, Subs, and Salad at Taranto's Pizza (Up to 54% Off). Four Options Available.

Taranto's Pizza

South Columbus

$20.26 $10

Large one- or three- topping pizzas pair with side options like sodas, crisp salad, and fragrant garlic bread—or just more pizzas

$17 for $30 Worth of Pub Food and Non-Alcoholic Drinks at Plank's Bier Garten

Plank's Bier Garten

Brewery District

$30 $17

Bratwursts, burgers, braunschweiger sandwiches, and pizza headline menu at German Village mainstay

Pizza Dinner for Two or Four with Drinks or Takeout at bonoPIZZA (Up to 43% Off)

bonoPIZZA

Columbus

$22 $13

(10)

Hand-tossed, wood-fired 10" pizzas topped with ingredients such as coconut, sauerkraut, and fresh pesto

$10 for Two Groupons, Each Good for $10 Worth of Pizza at Mikey's Late Night Slice ($20 Total Value)

Mikey's Late Night Slice

Multiple Locations

$10 $5

Late-night Columbus staple features fresh pizza, subs, and vegetarian and vegan options, served with attitude

Specialty Pizza Meals for Two or Four, or Take-Out or Delivery from Ange's Pizza - Clintonville (Up to 51% Off)

Anges Pizza - Clintonville

Clintonville

$25.05 $15

Custmoize pizzas with up to five toppings, paired with salads, appetizers, wings, and drinks; take-out and delivery option available

$11 for $20 Worth of Italian Bar Bites at Lucé Nuovo

Lucé Nuovo

Powell

$20 $11

(59)

Fried ravioli, crab-cake bites, stromboli, and Italian takes on burgers fill a new bar menu; live jazz on Thursday evenings

Italian Dinner for Two or Four or Carryout at Mia Cucina (Up to 42% Off)

Mia Cucina

Powell

$25 $15

(116)

Italian food such as gnocchi with blue cheese and pan-fried salmon with capers and angel-hair pasta

Italian Food for Carry-Out or Delivery from Village Pizzeria (Up to 42% Off). Two Options Available.

Village Pizzeria

Dublin/Powell

$19 $11

Homemade dough, pasta, and sausage star in specialty pizzas, stuffed strombolis, ample slices of lasagna, and oven-baked subs

$10 for $20 Worth of Pizzas, Sandwiches, and Pasta at Captain 9’s

Captain 9's

Germantown

$20 $10

(44)

Pizza, pasta, Hershey's ice cream, and subs in a diner decorated with authentic firefighter suits

$11 for $21 Worth of Italian Food at DeCheco's Pizzeria

DeCheco's Pizzeria

Firestone Park

$21 $11

Hot wings and meatball subs served up alongside unique pizzas smothered in creamy garlic sauce or topped with potatoes and sour cream

$10 for $20 Worth of Pizza, Subs, and Drinks for Dine-In Service at Mio’s Pizzeria

Mio's Pizzeria

Miami

$20 $10

(54)

Original-crust pizza topped with wholesome cheese and tangy tomato sauce, along with hoagies, calzones, and stuffed pizza

$11 for $20 Worth of Pizza and Subs or a Pizza Meal for Four at D'Tutanelli's Pizza

D'Tutanelli's Pizza

Amherst

$20 $11

Specialty pizzas such as T-Rex—with bacon, sausage, ham, meatballs, and pepperoni—classic Margherita Pie, pesto pizza, and chicken philly

Select Local Merchants

Purveying pizzas and subs is a family affair for the friendly staffers at Flyers, who have been offering patrons saucy circulars and savory sandwiches since 1976. Like the devastating barrage of cake and ice cream that the Air Force drops on other countries during their birthday, The Bomber signature pizza bombards unsuspecting tasters with palatable flavors, particularly its combination of provolone cheese, mushroom, green peppers, and a gathering of meats ($7.99 for stromboli, $13.99 for 11"; $17.49 for 13"; $19.99 for 15"). Peruse pizza and sandwich options here.

962 N Waggoner Rd
Blacklick,
OH
US

PaPa Joe’s menu (varies slightly between locations) specializes in replacing stomach voids with satisfying subs and tasty pizzas. Start with an eight-piece arrangement of wings ($4.95) whose sauces are kept secret unless you can guess your server’s middle name and favorite Muppet. After an antipasto salad ($6) spiced up with pepperoni, mushrooms, salami, tomatoes, and non-faux cheese, procure a personal seven-inch pizza ($4.25) with a topping of your choice. Or give your body’s gas tank a fright with one of PaPa Joe’s famous two-foot monster pizzas ($32.95 with one topping). You can also add extra summer to your summer by gargling a 10-inch Hawaiian pizza ($11.95)—which includes ham, bacon, black olives, and pineapple chunks—or sample all nine inches of the popular non-pizza, the richboy sub ($5.50+), served with ham, salami, peppers, and mozzarella.

6784 Refugee Rd
Canal Winchester,
OH
US

Marco's Pizza founder Pasquale "Pat" Giammarco began helping out at his family?s pizzeria when he was just a boy. The eatery provided a taste of home to the Giammarco clan, who moved to the United States from Italy when Pat was 9 years old. Together with his father, young Pat learned the secrets to creating exceptional pizza sauce: three types of vine-ripened tomatoes and spices that can only be imported from Italy or the moon.

The perfected sauce recipe continues to guide Pat?s kitchen operations?although, these days he has considerably more help. Marco's Pizza has 350 locations in more than half the states as well as in the Bahamas, each store tossing fresh pizza dough daily before sprinkling on a trio of fresh, never-frozen cheeses.

8072 East Broad Street
Reynoldsburg,
OH
US

An outdoor patio makes dining al fresco at Pie's Gourmet Pizza Bistro a treat in warm weather. But should the rains drive guests inside, they'll find a pleasant scene there, too. The owners recently renovated the century-old home in which the restaurant is situated, putting a high polish on its rustic wood counters and arches. The food is even fresher than the renovations, a nice blend of signature pies such as chicken pesto and margherita rest upon a gourmet sourdough crust; and other housemade, locally-sourced delights such as ravioli and fried mozzarella. Items such as gourmet burgers, steak, and baked scallops round out the menu. For dessert, patrons dine on homemade ice cream.

7601 East Main Street
Reynoldsburg,
OH
US

Inside the kitchen at Kingy's Pizza Pub, cooks craft handmade pizzas rolled from fresh dough, slather housemade barbecue sauce onto slow-roasted ribs, and pour frosty glasses of draft beer. Kingy's pizza chefs and barbecue gurus have loaded their mantelpieces with prizes, including second place in the Canal Winchester Blues and Ribfest, People's Choice for best sauce at the Pickering Lions Club 2011 Pizza Challenge, and a Pulitzer Prize for being well-groomed. In addition to nibbling on nearby trophies, guests can chow down on hearty burgers after sharing baskets of boneless wings, tangy fried pickle spears, and cheese-covered fries.

7470 Hill Rd.
Canal Winchester,
OH
US

Butch's dedicated chefs build each of their Italian dishes from scratch, flavoring meats and pastas with sauces and dressings made fresh daily. They crown breaded chicken parmigiana with marinara, mozzarella, and grilled mushrooms, and they ladle crimson meat sauce over penne with grilled shrimp. In the dining room, marigold walls surround tables weighed down by thick cuts of lasagna, and a shiny, mocha-hued floor yields a mirrored reflection.

6394 Gender Rd
Canal Winchester,
OH
US