Italian Restaurants in Compton Heights

Select Local Merchants

Serving the finest fresh pasta for over 25 years, Mangia Italiano is your home for good eats, cold drinks, and cool groves.

3145 S Grand Blvd
Saint Louis,
MO
US

Since 1981, the pizza specialists at Elicia's Pizza have zipped through St. Louis's tangled roads delivering piping-hot pies to households in 30 minutes or less. At the shop, marinara masters stretch house-made dough into the shape of a mad professor's monocle and lavish each thin-crust disk with fresh sauce and the house's three-cheese blend. Additionally, the pizzeria's menu celebrates casual eats, such as wings, baked pastas, sandwiches, and crisp salads.

3209 Gravois Ave.
Saint Louis,
MO
US

Pint glasses fill with fresh drafts of craft beers from Parma Grill and Tap's microbrewery while cooks prepare platters of Italian fare, such as lasagna and eggplant parmesan, inside the kitchen. A selection of specialty pizzas includes buffalo chicken with blue-cheese or ranch dipping sauce and Elizabeth's Favorite, a vegetable pizza topped with roasted eggplant and fresh tomatoes.

3000 South Jefferson Avenue
St. Louis,
MO
US

Cini, named for the Italian street food arancini, packs its menu with a variety of these traditional rice balls that are crispy on the outside and packed with fresh veggies and meat on the inside. Guests first pick their cini of choice as their appetizer, with options including the Original packed with sausage and peas, a Primavera cini with zucchini and squash, or the four-cheese rice ball. From there, customers can select a base for their main meal, choosing either a thin-crust wrap called a piadina, a bowl of angel-hair or penne pasta, or a salad bowl of mixed greens. The wrap, pasta, or salad is then topped with a grill item such as meatballs, salmon, or steak and then adorned with a choice of hot or cold sauces such as fresh basil pesto, pomodoro, or creamy parmesan. And for dessert, the meal comes full circle with the addition of a sweet cini stuffed with hazelnut chocolate and sweet arborio rice.

374 S Grand Blvd
Saint Louis,
MO
US

Start off your decadent dinner feast with creamy mushroom risotto ($6) and a fresh mixed-green salad with balsamic vinaigrette ($3.50/$6) before moving on to the main event. Each night, the talented chef and kitchen staff at Spaghetteria Mamma Mia feature three pastas—one long, one short, and one stuffed. Aside from the three pasta specialties, try the stuffed tilapia with shrimp, crab, and clams, gingerly splashed with a white wine lemon butter sauce ($18), or satisfy your meat-tooth with an indulgent veal saltimbocca (with a sherry sauce, sage, and prosciutto, $16). For a more informal feast, savor a roasted-garlic, spinach, mozzarella and mushroom pizza ($12) with a glass of wine ($5–$9), or a spaghetti Sicily, composed of two large meatballs surrounded by classic spaghetti ($10). Finish your meal with one of Spaghetteria Mamma Mia's desserts made fresh daily.

904 South Vandeventer Avenue
Saint Louis,
MO
US

At Black Bear Bakery, every batch of Lickhalter sourdough-rye bread, sweet pastries, and crunchy granola is made with the care of a shop owner. That’s because each staff member serves as a partial owner of the communal shop. This makes each staff member feel a personal responsibility for creating a shop they’d like their family to come to, encouraging them to use eco-friendly processes and locally sourced, organic ingredients. Along with whole-grain recipes filled with specialty ingredients such as kalamata olives and rosemary, bakers use century-old recipes passed down from the owners of Lickhalter Bakery. These recipes create hearty sourdough-rye loaves sprinkled with caraway seeds or twisted together with pumpernickel dough.

While breads are their specialty, bakers fill their ovens with more than just bread loaves. They craft handmade, boiled bagels that come sans holes, as well as cookies, baked granola, pizza crusts, and a variety of buns. On the weekends, they welcome the community for a vegetarian and vegan brunch, which features staples such as pancakes, quiche, potatoes, and bread pudding made from their loaves. These dishes can be washed down with pours of fair trade coffee, juice, tea, or pastry filling.

2639 Cherokee St
Saint Louis,
MO
US