Restaurants in Sayville

Select Local Merchants

Grey Horse Tavern is proud to support small farms and local producers. Everything we prepare is made from scratch, using the best seasonal, sustainable, and organic ingredients available.

291 Bayport Ave
Bayport,
NY
US

Fusion 84’s cosmopolitan menu takes palates on a culinary tour of the world with exotic sauces and spices, fillets of fresh seafood, juicy steaks, and poultry. Like Cary Grant’s unplaceable accent, the tantalizing bill of fare draws influences from throughout the globe, blending Asian, Caribbean, European, and southern traditions in tasty small plates such as the mini blue crab tacos ($9) stuffed with citrus jicama slaw and garnished with pico de gallo.

296 W Main St
Sayville,
NY
US

Great Restaurants of Long Island has reviewed 21 Main Prime Steak House. Zagat rated the food, décor, and service at 21 Main Prime Steak House as very good to excellent, and 89% of more than 230 reviewers like the restaurant. Eighty-seven percent of Urbanspooners like 21 Main Prime Steak House, and OpenTable reviewers give it an average of 4.3 stars.

21 Main St
West Sayville,
NY
US

O’Reilly’s flame-wielders dish up an eclectic menu of traditional Irish-pub fare amid fetching period décor and games fit for the whole family. Imbue taste buds with the savory flavors of a twice-baked shrimp potato ($7.48) before unbridling a gallant fleet of forks upon a legion of irish-sausage links straddled with mashed potatoes and sautéed onions ($14.98). Or invoke the Earl of Sandwich without donning a fluffernutter-encrusted crown by perusing O’Reilly’s selection of handheld eats, which includes the succulent short-rib grilled-cheese sandwich slathered in horseradish sauce ($10.48) and the Bookmaker—a robust layering of filet mignon, sautéed onions, and mushrooms ($13.48). Homemade by O’Reilly’s crack chefs, the strawberry-rhubarb cobbler robes itself with regal dollops of whipped and sweetened Jameson butter ($4.98).

927A Montauk Hwy
Oakdale,
NY
US

Located next to the bobbing boats of a marina, Kingston's Clam Bar serves up fresh air alongside its fresh seafood. Red umbrellas shade a row of tables outside along the dock, and French doors admit sea breezes into the dining room. There, servers crisscross the red brick floor with morsels on casual, plastic plates, such as a lobster roll stuffed with lemon-mayo dressing and tender chilled meat.

130 Atlantic Ave
West Sayville,
NY
US