Following in the footsteps of their father, the three Coli brothers aim to capture the flavors and traditions of classic Chicago cuisine with their slate of hearty comfort fare. Backed by a team of chefs, they forge Georgio's Chicago Pizzeria and Pub’s trademark deep-dish pizzas from a more than 60-year-old recipe, kept hidden to preserve its authenticity and hand-model-caliber hands. The hefty pies, along with their crispy thin-crust cohorts, were declared the best pizza in McHenry County by readers of the Northwest Herald, and helped the eatery garner a slot on Pizza Today magazine’s list of the Hot 100 Independent pizzerias in 2011. The brothers complement their acclaimed creations with a roster of pasta and sandwiches, dished up amid a sleek, upscale sports-bar atmosphere. Both locations are decked out in flat-screen TVs and reclaimed exposed brick.. The comfortable environs regularly play host to fundraisers and events, such as dinners that pair the Coli brothers’ prize-winning pizzas with a lineup of craft beers on tap.
Old Town serves saucy pastas, cheesy sandwiches, and pizzas in varying dimensions. Build your own medium cheese pie on one of five crusts: thin ($12.50); double dough ($13.65); or deep dish, Chicago style, or Sicilian-style stuffed, which has all four smaller crusts stuffed inside it ($15.40 each). Choose from one of Old Town's specialty 'zas, such as a medium veggie ($19.20), barbecue chicken ($17.90), or the meat-tastic Butcher's Block ($19.20). Pasta dishes are all less than $10, and include noodley hits such as baked lasagna and chicken parmesan ($9.55 each). Old Town also specializes in subs, burgers, and sandwiches ($6.25 and under), as well as fried panzarotti and baked calzones, otherwise known as Italian Hot Pockets ($7.50–8.95).
Zio Giovanni's hardworking pizza architects and pasta chefs tantalize palates with savory pies and mouthwatering plates of traditional Italian cuisine. Ladlefuls of house-made sauce drape noodles in tasty coats of rich pomodoro, tangy puttanesca, and creamy alfredo, as flavorful toppings such as plum tomatoes, peppers, and artichoke hearts crown toasty pizzas. The charming interior tastefully frames Italian feasts with cloth-clad tables and mirrored walls, while facilitating human-chess tournaments with earth-toned checkered floors.
Like a stick figure's head, pizza is round and has stuff on it. Eat some circle-y dinner with today's Groupon: for $10, you get $20 worth of awesome pizza, refreshing drinks, and other really cool meals at Barnaby's Family Inn in Schaumburg.