Italian Restaurants in Sheboygan

Sandwich or Pizza Meal with Gellato for Two or Four at Mancino's Pizza & Grinders (Up to 49% Off)

Mancino's Pizza & Grinders

Multiple Locations

$21.48 $11

(72)

Sandwiches from meatball subs to Cuban grinders; pizzas decorated with gyro meat, feta, and other adventurous toppings

Two Large Pizzas or Pizza, Sandwiches, and Appetizers for Dine-In or Takeout from Tarantino (Up to 50% Off)

Tarantino

Fairview

$31 $16

Shrimp and black olive specialty pizza highlights a menu of pizzas, pasta, hot sandwiches, and appetizers

Medium or Extra-Large Thin Crust Pizza Meal with Garlic Bread Sticks and Soda from Pizzeria Scotty (43% Off)

Pizzeria Scotty

West View

$19.18 $11

Carryout or delivery thin crust pizzas served with deep-fried garlic bread sticks and soda

$15 for $30 Worth of Italian Food and Drinks at Michael's Italian Restaurant

Michael's Italian Restaurant

Waukesha

$30 $15

Homemade pizza crusts and pastas topped with ladles of scratch-made sauce; fresh fish flown in from Chicago every morning

$10 for $20 Worth of Italian Cuisine at Casa Di Giorgio

Casa Di Giorgio

Casa di Giorgio

$20 $10

(19)

Authentic Italian pasta, pizzas, and specialties pair with fine wines amid chandeliers and vibrant oil paintings

$5.99 for a Large One-Topping Pizza from Papa Murphy's ($11 Value)

Papa Murphy's

Delavan

$11 $5.99

Take ‘N’ Bake pizzas with fresh dough topped with ingredients in customized or pre-selected combos

Pizza Meal for Two or Four with Appetizer Sampler and Soft Drinks at Rocky's Pizzeria (Up to 54% Off)

Rocky's Pizzeria

Lindenhurst

$21.72 $10

Bite into your choice of three appetizers, such as chicken fingers, tater tots, and fried shrimp, plus handmade cheese pizzas

$13 for $20 Worth of Pizza for Delivery or Takeout at Mike's Pizza

Mike's Pizza

Gages Lake

$10 $6.50

Create your own deep dish or hand tossed pizza from 15 toppings, 3 crust flavors, and sauces such as alfredo or barbecue

$21 for $40 Worth of Neapolitan Cuisine at Naples 15

Naples 15

Old Market Place

$40 $21

(16)

Chef from Naples, Italy, offers cuisine such as fresh scallops, shrimp, and mussels over linguine and ziti with a three-meat ragu sauce

Pizza Meal for Two or Four at Dahmen's Pizza Place (Up to 47% Off)

Dahmen's Pizza Place

Madison

$25.45 $14

(115)

Guests dine on pizzas topped with basil, Italian sausage, mushrooms, and Canadian bacon, sided with draft beers and breadsticks

Select Local Merchants

Pino Piroso dedicated himself to founding a distinctive, Roman-style pizzeria, saying that "after years of hard work, we knew we had built something very special." His lauded chain eventually grew to include franchises in six states and two countries outside of the United States. Despite their geographic separation, each location has the same stringent standards for their ingredients and their Exit-sign locations. No kitchen stores pizza fixings in a freezer—instead, the cooks begin every morning by stirring sauces, kneading dough, and dicing fresh seasonal toppings from local farms. The circular or rectangular pies can support as many as 33 of these familiar and nontraditional toppings, such as goat cheese, sweet corn, and roasted chicken.

1228 12th Ave
Grafton,
Wisconsin
US

Downtown Pizza’s chefs crown their signature pies with inventive toppings such as hawaiian jerk sauce and sliced corned beef before pairing them with wings, pastas, or gooey desserts. Tufted leather booths squeak as diners vie for the final slices of German pizza loaded with sauerkraut, bratwurst, and potatoes or steamy pot-pie pizzas that pile tender bits of chicken atop rosemary-crumble crust. Vegetarian pizzas arrive slathered in creamy pesto sauce or topped with marinated mock duck, and six varieties of sauce souse the breaded and baked chicken wings. Hanging lights emit a soft glow that accents the retro pizzeria’s red and turquoise walls on which vintage plates and kitschy salt and pepper shakers perch in shadowboxes and await puppet-show requests.

1228 12th Ave
Grafton,
WI
US

Cuisine Type: Italian and American

Established: 2008

Reservations: Optional

Handicap Accessible: Yes

Number of Tables: 11?25

Parking: Parking lot

Most Popular Offering: Pizza, baked pasta, specialty sandwiches

Kid-friendly: Yes

Alcohol: None

Delivery/Takeout Available: Yes

Outdoor Seating: No

The Herberts' dream was to open their own family restaurant. Their made-from-scratch pizzas and bubbling baked pastas were so successful that the family was able to open a second Michaleno?s Pizzeria. Their shop in Kewaskum focuses on carryout and delivery, while the one in West Bend has plenty of space for folks to dine inside.

The Herberts work alongside family and friends to craft fresh pizza dough every day. Even the recipes for homemade marinara, pizza sauce, and dough are a family affair. Together, they create thin-crust and double-crust stuffed pizzas crowned with such toppings as gyro meat and bacon bits.

Michaleno's extensive menu also features fried chicken and wings, seafood dinners, and sandwiches.

250 Main St
Kewaskum,
WI
US

Casa Anna Cheese Store is arguably Wisconsin’s cheese epicenter. Consider: the shop is situated inside the historic Park Cheese factory, which has produced italian cheeses for more than 70 years. Store shelves sag with the weight of more than 130 types of cheese, including cheese curds, aged cheddar, and smoked gouda. And cheesehead paraphernalia is sprinkled throughout the shop, paying tribute to a cheese-based economy rivaled only by the moon's. It’s all part of owners Lewis and Cindy Blank's mission to support and showcase local cheese artisans. In addition to stocking blocks of cheese, they also assemble take-and-bake pizzas loaded with layers of the Dairy Land's best.

204 W Division St
Fond Du Lac,
WI
US

The ovens at Mancino's Pizza & Grinders ripple with heat, distorting the sight of inventively topped pies and grinders that have won praise from Taste of Fond du Lac, whose winners are marked in red on the eatery's menu. Atop tables draped in red-and-white-checkered tablecloths, slices covered in seasoned beef and salsa imitate tacos, and beef, ketchup, and mustard help pies perfectly recreate the flavor of the Declaration of Independence. Delivery drivers rush past, testing their arm strength with 18-inch grinders, which spill forth toppings such as chicken fajita strips, salami, meatballs, and corned beef.

818 S Main St.
Fond Du Lac,
WI
US

The dough wizards at Papa John's hand toss circular masterpieces with original and thin crusts made from high-protein flour to support warm bouquets of toppings. Hand-cut produce crowns all of Papa John's pizzas, mingling with the sun-soaked sweetness of sauce made from fresh, California-grown tomatoes. By adhering to its brand promise of "better ingredients, better pizza," Papa John's grew from a back-tavern pizzeria into more than 3,500 restaurants within three decades' time, or the amount of time it takes to grow a single pizzeria from a small seed.

459 West Johnson Street
Fond Du Lac,
WI
US