Bakeries in South Farmingdale

Select Local Merchants

As detailed in a segment on Restaurant Hunter on FiOS1, the plain bagel is Stuff A Bagel's best seller, though the everything bagel a close second. Following a recipe handed down to co-owners Phil and Lisa Cirrone, the bagels are boiled and baked without adding preservatives. Besides bagels, Cirrone's team assembles hearty breakfast sandwiches or makes sweet blueberry pancakes, and bagels also serve as the basis for sandwiches at lunchtime, piled high with tuna, cheese, roast beef, and more.

234 Main St
Farmingdale,
NY
US

Muffins on Main Street bakes muffins and cakes from scratch every day. Not content to wait for customers to come to these baked treasures, the bakery delivers them straight to people's doors. Muffin enthusiasts can customize a dozen with flavors ranging from apple crumb to Oreo and have them delivered to their homes or a friend's home as a gift. The bakery also prearranges packages for chocolate lovers and birthday celebrations and creates scrumptious crumb cakes that beg to be excavated for their sweet flavor.

234 Main Street
Farmingdale,
NY
US

When the judges; scores came in, Sugar Rush Bakery's Andrew Mincher finished in second place on Food Network's Cupcake Wars. Going into the competition, he thought, "This is what I do and I thought, I’m going to have fun doing it." His positive attitude—and his recipe for banana-rum cupcakes with peanut-butter buttercream frosting—paid off.

The recognition came as a hefty endorsement for the brand-new owner of the former Di Monda Bakery. Mincher recently bought out the business with his dad and brother so that he could make cupcakes his way. Inside, customers find him doing exactly that, whipping together delicious cupcakes and other sweets such as cookies and fresh-baked breads. He decorates his creations with chunks of chocolate or cheerful frosting faces that seem to ask, "Do I look cute in this foil?"

1030 Park Boulevard
Massapequa Park,
NY
US

The bakers at San Remo Bakery create crafty cakes and colorful macarons, in addition to seasonal cookies, Italian pastries, and fresh bread. Some of their more elaborate confections include cupcakes topped with frosting roses, a wedding cake with four pumpkin-shaped tiers, and a Thanksgiving cake that resembled a roast turkey.

943 N Broadway
Massapequa,
NY
US