Chosen by Zagat as one of the best steak houses in Westchester County, The Willett House quells discerning appetites with scrumptious steaks and seafood. On the prix fixe dinner menu, starters such as lobster bisque and gorgonzola salad prime bellies for entrees such as chicken francese and a 10-ounce filet mignon au poivre coated in a peppercorn cream sauce. After lulling anyone who eats it into a content, satiated slumber, the 2-pound lobster (an additional $5) infiltrates diners’ dreams and pinches them awake again. As they finish off the table’s shared bottle of wine, each patron can choose from a tray of fresh, house-made desserts and wash down the treat with a cup of coffee or tea. Surrounding the main dining room, a pressed-tin ceiling and exposed-brick walls augment the 90-square-foot mural depicting life in turn-of-the-century Port Chester, when the seaside town still led the world in exports of soda jerks’ red-striped hats.
People running in and out of the doors at Ribs on The Run used to be a common sight. That’s because the barbecue shop’s previous location was strategically located near a train stop, and hungry riders would run over, order some of their favorite ribs, and then be out the door to catch their train. Though the number of people sprinting to the door has decreased since their move to a new location, their clients still maintain the same level of fervor for the house’s signature ribs rubbed in secret spices. To create hearty meals, chefs pair their ribs, barbecue pork, and wings with cornbread and a choice of homestyle sides, which clients can eat in house, pick up in the restaurant, or have delivered free of charge. Staff can also cook up their filling fare for catered events, allowing loyal customers to share their favorite food with loved ones on their wedding days, at family reunions, or on the day they finally tell their dog he was adopted.
The main attraction at Mac's Steakhouse is a venerable selection of grass-fed steaks dry aged for at least 28 days. The gourmet cuts include 12-ounce new york strips served with potatoes au gratin, 16-ounce boneless rib eyes, and filets mignons that the New York Times lauds for their "velvety texture and well-made béarnaise sauce." Though the steaks may get top billing, they share the limelight with an estimable array of seafood, including grilled salmon, white tuna, and a sautéed shrimp-and-lobster combo served with vegetable risotto. Not to be outshined by the victuals, the restaurant's wine list traces the globe with varietals culled from California, France, Tuscany, Argentina, and Spain that have earned it an Award of Excellence from Wine Spectator.
To enter Mac's 7,000-square-foot interior, guests pass through 10-foot-high, 100-year-old carved wooden doors. They cross the threshold into a high-ceilinged space with 150-year-old wood-plank floors. Paintings of cattle adorn the walls, and guests can peer into a wine cellar tucked behind glass panels.
The classics reign supreme at Blackstones Steakhouse: a traditional restaurant devoted to special-occasion combinations of quality surf and turf. Inside the kitchen, cooks grill prime, dry-aged beef in a number of different cuts, ranging from a petite filet mignon to a porterhouse that can feed as many as four people. The steakhouse's chefs also fill the raw bar with oysters and clams on the half shell, and steam Maine lobsters over a pot of boiling iceberg shards.
Much like the menu, the steakhouse’s décor demonstrates a commitment to classical elegance and refinement. Walnut-hued wainscoting, earthenware floor tiles, and wine-red walls add a warm richness to the space. At the same time, stark white tables appear pristine in their simplicity, presenting diners with crisp napkins, crystal-clear wine glasses, and gleaming silverware.
Frank's Steaks has all the respectable hallmarks of an old-school steak house: white table cloths, neatly folded napkins, and dim lighting setting the mood. But then there are the crayons. They aren't there to keep kids busy—they're there so inspired diners of all ages can scrawl art onto the butcher paper atop each table. The most compelling works are framed and hung on the walls of the establishment, a fitting goal for diners to strive for when waiting for their mouthwatering steaks to arrive.
The signature Romanian skirt steak is certainly worth putting a crayon down for—the tender, juicy cut comes dripping in a marinade of garlic and duck sauce. A 42-ounce porterhouse, meanwhile, easily satisfies two diners or two medium-sized tanks of piranhas. Desserts also come in generous proportions, featuring smooth sorbets, triple-layer chocolate cake, and ice-cream pies.
Just beside the Bronx River, an early-1800's stone mill stretches above the water like the Space Shuttle perched hopefully over Cape Canaveral. The Georgian-style fieldstone building currently won't tear off for the cosmos, however. Instead, it plays host to The Olde Stone Mill restaurant, which makes use of the centuries-old timber posts and beams to create a cozy pastoral atmosphere, which is exactly what NASA first imagined to be the scene on the moon. The eatery's staff marries steak-house cuisine with Italian dishes, pairing pastas and veal francese with generous cuts of rib-eye and filet mignon. As a testament to the quality of this cuisine, Westchester Magazine named Olde Stone Mill's truffle ravioli the region's best in 2012 for its aromatic medley of wild mushrooms, cream, and truffle oil.
A goldenrod dining room, containing the building's original stone hearth, sets the scene for linguine twirling or tearing into porterhouse pork chops. Behind the handcrafted bar, bartenders pour glasses of wine and mix martinis, one of which won Westchester Magazine's praise as 2011's best twist on a traditional martini. Antique lanterns accented by spirals of ivy illuminate the bar's surface, and on balmy days, diners can retreat to the stone patio and enjoy their glasses of wine with a spritz of sunshine.