Italian Restaurants in Wantagh

49% Off Italian Meal at Carpe Diem

Carpe Diem

New Canaan

$115 $59

(10)

Customers enjoy appetizers such as grilled sea scallops before entrees of oven-roasted quail or housemade salmon ravioli with caviar

Up to 51% Off talian Cuisine at Solé

Solé

Oceanside

$50 $25

(113)

Chef Bobby Carmosino crafts Italian-inspired cuisine from fresh ingredients and some family recipes.

50% Off Italian Food

Nick's Tuscan Grill

Mineola

$60 $30

Lobster ravioli, sauteed lemon chicken, gorgonzola-crusted rib eye, and pizza with house-made meatballs

50% Off Italian Food at at Carlino’s Restaurant

Carlino’s Restaurant

Mineola

$50 $25

(11)

In Mineola Patch's 2012 Reader's Choice contest, fans selected the restaurant as the best place to get Italian food and pizza in the area

Up to 50% Off at Little Enrico's Pizzeria

Little Enrico's Pizzeria

Franklin Square

$24.02 $12

Eatery makes fresh pizza with toppings such as meatballs, anchovies, onions, and mushrooms, and pairs it with garlic bread and soda

Up to 52% Off at Massa's Pizzeria

Massa's Pizzeria

Massa's Coal Fired Brick Oven Pizzeria

$30 $15

(15)

Oven-baked pizzas with toppings such as mozzarella and San Marzano tomatoes; other Italian dishes include calzones and eggplant parmesan

50% Off Italian Lunch at Bravo! Nader

Bravo! Nader

Huntington

$29.90 $15

(307)

Twelve cozy tables are set with appetizers, soups, or salads, entrees such as veal parmesan or house-made gnocchi with pesto, and coffees

Half Off Italian Cuisine at La Bottega Mangia Bene

La Bottega Mangia Bene

Great Neck

$50 $25

(8)

Veal chops; pasta with sun-dried tomatoes; homemade paninis and salads; and pizza made from imported ingredients beside a dance floor

Up to 37% Off at Gallo Nero

Gallo Nero

New York

$30 $19

(135)

Italian restaurant dishes out antipasto with Portuguese octopus, bruschetta, baked meat tortellini, linguine with clams, and lamb shank

Up to 51% Off Three-Course Prix Fixe Dinner at Serafina

Serafina Meatpacking

Multiple Locations

$114 $59

(56)

Meals start with pizza, followed by choices that play on Northern Italian flavors, such as ravioli in sage sauce and sea bass

Up to 59% Off Italian Picnic

Pappardella

Upper West Side

$91 $39

(44)

Head over to Central Park for a picnic complete with Pappardella's antipasti, sandwiches, and desserts

Up to 47% Off Italian Dinner at Cucina di Pesce

Cucina Di Pesce

Bowery

$80 $45

Mussels, clams, and lobster enrich classic Italian sauces and pastas amid the urban charm of a former mob casino

40% Off Italian Cuisine at Vespa NYC

Vespa NYC

Upper East Side

$100 $60

Traditional, artisanal salumi and cheeses precede meat and pasta dishes based on the chef's family recipes

Up to 56% Off Italian Dinner for Two at Tre Stelle

Tre Stelle

Flat Iron

$103 $45

Filet mignon carpaccio, grilled veal tagliata with tomatoes and broccoli, and nutella cheesecake with ice cream

Half Off at Gente Ristorante Italiano

Gente Ristorante Italiano

Midtown Center

$80 $40

(162)

Zagat-rated Italian eatery with cuisine influenced directly by the chef’s frequent visits to Milan and other regions in Italy

Up to 33% Off Slice Of Brooklyn Pizzeria

Slice Of Brooklyn Pizzeria

Greenwood

$12 $8

Large pies lounge beneath toppings such as eggplant, meatballs & spinach at corner pizzeria

50% Off at Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza

Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza

Gramercy Park

$40 $20

(24)

Hand-tossed semolina dough slathered in housemade sauce and topped with fresh mozzarella before wood firing in a brick oven

38% Off Italian Cuisine at Radicchio Pasta & Risotto

Radicchio Pasta & Risotto

Midtown East

$40 $25

(102)

Cozy, rustic Italian eatery filled with homemade pasta, NY strip steak, grilled branzino and rich pesto sauces

38% Off Italian Cuisine at Tello's Ristorante

Tello's Ristorante

Chelsea

$65 $40

(90)

15-year-old Old-Country restaurant named after its head chef serves Italian classics, including imported meats and its signature braciole

49% Off Pizza Meal from Roberto's Pizza & Pasta

Roberto's Pizza & Pasta

New Rochelle

$26.50 $14

Choose from a menu of inventive pizza options, such as the philly cheesesteak pizza, the lasagna pizza, and the more traditional Meat Lovers

Up to 50% Off Italian Meal at Enzo's

Enzo's

Mamaroneck

$80 $40

(20)

Homemade pasta and flavorful chicken and steak dishes decorate linen-topped tables at eatery with outdoor seating

Portofino Restaurant – Up to 67% Off Surf 'n' Turf

Portofino Ristorante

New York

$223.85 $79

(46)

An Italian appetizer and dessert bookend a main course of Maine lobster tail and sirloin steak

Up to Half Off Catering from S&D Catering

S&D Catering

Schuylerville

$150.75 $75

Tender cold cuts top sandwiches; the buffet includes deli meats, homemade sausages, and pasta

Up to 58% Off at Harrison Pizza and Pasta

Harrison Pizza and Pasta

Harrison New York

$28.97 $14

Pizza dinners placate tongues with one-topping pizzas, salad, and ziti; catered chicken parmigiana brings a backup of mixed salads

Up to 50% Off Italian Cuisine at Mezini Restaurant & Lounge

Mezini Restaurant & Lounge

Park Slope

$50 $25

Elegant Italian restaurant features a raw bar stocked with freshly caught seafood

45% Off Pizza and Fusion Cuisine at CU 29 Copper

Cu 29 Copper

Williamsburg

$40 $22

(70)

Latin, Italian, and American dishes such as brick-oven pizza, shrimp scampi, skirt steak with chimichurri, and chipotle cheeseburgers

30% Off Italian and Mexican Food at Monsignor’s Restaurant

Monsignor's Restaurant

Greenwood

$50 $35

(71)

Appetizers such as fried calamari and garlic-cheese bread precede entrees of goat-cheese ravioli and mushroom pasta

50% Off Italian Food at Ristorante Vaccaro

Ristorante Vaccaro

Dyker Heights

$50 $25

Italian restaurant serves up classic dishes such as mozzarella di bufala caprese salad and pollo alla vaccaro with chicken and shrimp

Up to 60% Off Pizza Meal for Two at Nice Pizza

Nice Pizza

Brooklyn

$45 $18

Pizzas inspired by the south of France include a 16-inch pie with grilled marinated chicken and a cheese pizza with a choice of toppings

Half Off Italian Cuisine at Il Posto

Il Posto

Bergen Beach

$30 $15

(13)

Chef Nino, an area favorite, helms the kitchen as plates come out with homemade pasta, fresh seafood, and signature tiramisu

Up to 51% Off Pizza Meal at Casa Edesia

Casa Edesi

Bath Beach

$30.50 $15

Family-owned trattoria makes guests feel at home with hearty New York–style pies

50% Off Italian Food at Mamma Cucina's

Mamma Cucina's

Ronkonkoma

$30 $15

(18)

Baked ziti, chicken parmigiana, and veal cutlets alongside Buffalo wings and a full wine list

50% Off Italian Dinner at Spezia

Spezia

St. James

$50 $25

Hearty Italian entrees—such as the lasagna; housemade pastas and sauces; and veal, chicken, and seafood entrees—can comfort diners

Half Off at Fifth Avenue Pizza

Fifth Avenue Pizza

Pelham

$24 $12

Extensive menu catalogs specialty pizzas such as bacon chicken ranch plus sandwiches, calzones, wings, and pasta entrees

Up to 47% Off at Sal's Pizza

Sal's Pizza and Italian Kitchen

College Point

$20 $11

(15)

Classic, stuffed, and sicilian-style pizzas alongside baked pastas, grilled panini, calzones, hot subs, and desserts like Oreo zeppole

Up to 57% Off Italian Dinner at Il Sogno Ristorante

Il Sogno Ristorante

Port Chester

$92 $40

(103)

Praised by the New York Times, the Italian eatery's year-round and seasonal specialties include lobster ravioli in creamy aurora sauce.

Up to 49% Off Italian Dinner and Wine

Bella Nonna Restaurant and Pizzeria

Greenwich

$68.40 $35

Italian classics ranging from pasta tossed in fresh-made sauces to fire-kissed pizzas and house-made desserts

Up to 44% Off Italian Meal with Wine at Cacio e Vino

Cacio e Vino

East Village

$58 $35

Sip on house wine while snacking on appetizers such as fried calamari, sicilian rice balls, or eggplant Parmesan

Up to 48% Off Dinner at B & Co.

B & Co.

Midtown Center

$188 $99

(12)

Organic, local, and grass-fed ingredients—often from local farms—mix into upscale Italian and Mediterranean dishes

50% Off at Ornella Trattoria Italiana

Ornella Trattoria Italiana

Ditmars Steinway

$50 $25

(157)

Italian food including prosciutto di parma, penne with San Marzano tomato sauce, spaghetti carbonara, and salmone primavera

$10 for Italian Food at Michael Anthony's Pizza

Michael Anthony's Pizza

Centereach

$20 $10

(5)

Cooks kick out authentic Italian pastas, veal and chicken entrees, and pizzas, including gluten-free pies

Up to 50% Off at Tiny's Pizza & Pasta

Tiny's Pizza & Pasta

Fleetwood - Concourse Village

$20 $11

(15)

Specialty pizza incorporate ingredients from traditional Italian dishes including lasagna, baked ziti, and pasta primavera

Up to 50% Off Dinner at Casa Rina of Thornwood

Casa Rina of Thornwood

Thornwood

$60 $30

(17)

Award-winning restaurant dishes up filet mignon, traditional pasta dishes, and specialty martinis in a spacious and inviting atmosphere

50% Off at Tomāto Tomäto Pizzeria & Pour House

Tomāto Tomäto Pizzeria & Pour House

Stamford

$20 $10

Eatery serves classic Italian starters and entrees, many of which feature house-made tomato sauce, with thin-crust pizza and libations

50% Off Italian Food at Figaro Villaggio

Figaro Villaggio

East Village

$40 $20

Charming corner bistro serves classic Italian favorites

Up to 50% Off at Convo Bar

Convo Bar

Midtown

$40 $20

Appetizers such as rosemary focaccia, garlic shrimp, and meatballs sliders precede wood-fired pizzas dressed in italian sausage and basil

Up to 44% Off Italian Dinner & Wine at Intermezzo

Intermezzo

Chelsea

$79.40 $45

Family-recipe Italian meals served amid black-and-white photos and crystal chandeliers that evoke midcentury glamour

Up to 61% Off Pasta Bistro Grill

Pasta Bistro Grill

Greenwich Village

$20 $10

After PEI clams or eggplant fritters, diners dive into almond-crusted lamb or grilled swordfish before cannoli or mud cake

Up to 53% Off Upscale Italian Dinner at Re Sette

Re Sette

Midtown Center

$100 $49

(139)

Gothic-styled eatery near Theater District with southern Italian-inspired dishes from brick-oven pizzas to fresh homemade pastas

Up to 60% Off at Crudo Cucina & Vineria

Crudo Cucina & Vineria

NoLita

$56 $25

(34)

Authentic Italian small plates, such as fried calamari and bruschetta, delight palates while sipping drinks and enjoying live music

30% Off Northern Italian Cuisine at Da Noi

Da Noi

Shore Acres

$50 $35

(18)

Old-world Northern Italian dishes such as thick, sage-scented veal chops and house-made pasta

50% Off at Goodfella's Old World Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta

Goodfella's Old World Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta

Dongan Hills

$30 $15

(80)

Enjoy award-winning brick-oven pizzas and Italian entrees and pastas in a bistro setting or at home

Select Local Merchants

High ceilings with exposed piping lend a modern vibe to Toro Pazzo and serve as a foil to a menu of time-tested Italian dishes. Executive chef Alan Pucci, a native of Lucca, Italy, draws upon an array of Italian meats such as prosciutto and sopressata as well as olives, grilled artichoke hearts, and fontina, gorgonzola, and pecorino cheeses. In the bustling kitchen, the crew rolls dough into potato gnocchi and fresh rigatoni, which fill pasta dishes and sate diners before trips to the National Dry Macaroni Card Museum. Curlicues of steam unfurl from veal scallopini with fresh sage and prosciutto and pistachio-encrusted salmon in a lemon beurre blanc.

Behind Toro Pazzo's bar, an indoor waterfall trickles as mixologists concoct dessert cocktails such as vodka-infused root-beer floats or birthday-cake martinis with sprinkle-encrusted rims. Brimming with bottles imported from Sardinia and Tuscany, the wine list offers pairing for any dish, and on some evenings live bands fill the eatery with lilting guitar strains.

753 Wantagh Ave
Wantagh,
NY
US

Despite the promise of pizza implicit in its name, mr.Pies' hidden gem—at least according to customers—actually lies in the menu's appetizer section. Doused in fiery buffalo sauce, served with blue cheese for dipping, and offset by crunchy celery, the buffalo wings draw a comparable amount of eaters as the pizza. Don't fret if you can't choose between the two—you can get buffalo chicken scattered right across your pie. Or skip wings and pizza all together, and dig into a traditional Italian pasta dish instead.

3255 Sunrise Hwy
Wantagh,
NY
US

Some of New York's most familiar faces have been spotted enjoying Umberto's award-winning pizza. Rudy Giuliani. Eli Manning. Victor Cruz. The Statue of Liberty whenever a lightning storm reanimates her. There are more complex entrees as well—including seafood marinara with clams, scungilli, mussels, lobster, and calamari—but the crown jewel of the menu remains the specialty pizzas strewn with authentically Italian toppings such as meatballs and broccoli rabe.

1180 Wantagh Ave
Wantagh,
NY
US

Brooklyn Square Pizza expertly rolls out Brooklyn-style square pizzas, adorning the doughy geometric shape in eclectic toppings such as barbecue chicken, eggplant, and broccoli. Chefs also craft round pizza crusts so shy toppings cannot hide in the corners, and fill plates with pasta and chicken recipes made fresh to order. For those who abhor utensils, the pizzeria offers handheld fare such as heroes, wraps, and fried calzones. Uncle Louie G italian ice or ice cream treats tongues to flavors such as lick me lemon, chocolate fudge brownie, and bubbly bubble gum. Brooklyn Square Pizza delivers its fare to patrons’ doorsteps and caters parties with pasta, chicken, veal, and shrimp dishes.

3620 Merrick Rd
Seaford,
NY
US

At Vincent's Pizza, experienced chefs use fresh ingredients to whirl together pizzas, pastas, and other Italian cuisine. The menu includes specialty pizzas with whole-wheat crusts, grilled chicken and broccoli rabe wraps, and traditional entrees, such as meat lasagna.

3882 Merrick Rd
Seaford,
NY
US

The menu at Frank's Pizza & Restaurant is divided into stripes of red, white, and green, emulating the Italian flag while collecting dishes from across the country. Chicken marsala arrives as an entree with a dinner salad or tops a thin-crust pizza, tossed from traditional, whole-wheat, or gluten-free dough. The kitchen also presses broccoli rabe paninis, tosses linguine with fried calamari, and nods to American cuisine with chicken fingers and a collection of domestic beers.

1095 N Broadway
North Massapequa,
NY
US