Bakeries in Watertown

Select Local Merchants

Sweet Creations 4U serves baked goods, sandwiches, and sweets along with coffee and espresso drinks from Stone Creek Coffee. Selections range from gourmet chocolates and Norske Nook pie filling to barbecue pulled-pork sandwiches and Amy's gourmet apples.

39 North Main Street
Hartford,
WI
US

Owned by the Nimmow family, who channel long-loved family recipes with Amish roots, Golden Days Bakery proffers a panoply of preservative-free confections that are made from scratch each day. Moist fruit pies ($4.25 for mini, $8.50 for large) boast local notoriety for their tasty fillings that include rhubarb strawberry, pecan, and pumpkin. Diverse grains assemble into a bounty of fluffy breads ($2.95–$3.25) such as homemade dinner rolls, health-packed flax seed, cinnamon-swathed monkey bread, and apple, cherry, or cream-cheese danishes that speak perfect English. Mouthwatering cookie classics ($4.75/dozen) such as sugar, chocolate chip, and oatmeal raisin quell crunch cravings among sweet teeth and very hungry hippos, and even the pickiest appetites are sure to find appeasement in assorted treats such as cashew brittle, Oreo truffles, or caramel pecan bars.

956 W Main St
Sun Prairie,
WI
US

Becky’s Blissful Bakery’s confectionists eschew high-fructose corn syrup or preservatives, instead, they handcraft most batches of gluten-free caramels from organic ingredients—including some from other local merchants. Along with the original vanilla-caramel recipe, flavors such as masala chai tea from Rishi Tea or extra-special bitter beer from Lakefront Brewery infuse the treats with added complexity. Rather than protecting each caramel by wrapping it in peanut butter, Becky’s bakers swaddle the morsels in wax paper before arranging them in packages accented with silver bows.

214 Oakton Ave
Pewaukee,
WI
US

At Rich’s House of Cakes, cake designers create towering, artistic pastries for weddings and celebrations of all kinds. Cakes are made from scratch with all-natural ingredients and served as tortes, with fillings such as custard, chocolate fudge, or blueberry running between two layers of cake. Specialty fillings such as amaretto, Oreo cookie, and cream cheese add a personal touch to custom cakes without the hassle of making them into a life-sized mold of your face.

821 Meadowbrook Road
Waukesha,
WI
US

Family Owned, specialize in authentic italian Bakery/Breads/Sweets. Full-service Deli including Deli Meats, Panini's, Sandwiches, Soups. Spaghetti Dinner on Wed Nights from 5 - 7 pm runs October thru April. Dine in or Carry Out

N88W16672 Main St
Menomonee Falls,
WI
US

At Yo Cool Frozen Yogurt, panels in the bright-blue walls reveal shiny chrome yogurt dispensers. Pull down a handle and fill your cup with rotating flavors that might include peanut butter, strawberry shortcake, and dutch chocolate. Then go wild and pile on as much candy, fresh fruit, and syrup toppings as your sweet tooth can handle. Mix angel-food-cake frozen yogurt with peppermint syrup, or hide gummy worms in your cake-batter yogurt. To combat the chill of your frozen dessert, pair it with a hot english-toffee coffee, apple cider, or chai latte, or just zip up your parka before every spoonful.

N78 w14579 Appleton Ave
Menomonee Falls,
WI
US