Italian Restaurants in Winter Springs

Select Local Merchants

Our story starts with two friends with entrepreneurial spirit and a passion for America's favorite food. We opened up our first Pizzeria in central Florida in 1987, realizing the importance of freshness, ease of operation and variety.

5256 Red Bug Lake Rd
Winter Springs,
FL
US

Tuscany's chefs craft traditional Italian fare with zest, populating a menu with pasta, pizza, sandwiches, and chicken dishes. Patrons can catapult a hearty portion of baked ziti down gullets ($9.99), or savor the event by starting with a fried calamari appetizer ($8.99) and a complete recitation of My Dinner with Andre the Giant. Chicken entrees rest on a davenport of pasta and include parmesan, picatta, marsala, and francese varieties ($12.99 each). Pizza lovers have nine specialties pies to choose from, such as bacon white pizza ($14.99) and its arch nemesis, broccoli white pizza ($14.49). The eatery also boasts a hefty collection of 11 sammies good for lunch or dinner, including a meatball parm sub ($7.99) and the Cyclops ($13.99), which can serve up to four people wearing two horse costumes.

1301 Winter Springs Blvd
Winter Springs,
FL
US

200 E State Road 434
Winter Springs,
FL
US

Lil Anthony is a New York–style pizzeria, which means it dishes up thin-crust pizza by the pie and by the slice and accompanies it with a menu loaded with wings, pasta, salads, and subs. Introduce your taste buds to Italy’s flavors with an order of garlicky cheesy knots with marinara ($3.99) before sending them on the tour of Italy, a trio of the eatery's favorite pasta dishes: lasagna, fettuccini alfredo, and baked cheese ravioli ($13.99). Lil Anthony's pizzas come in traditional varieties, such as classic meat lover's ($13.99 and up) and gourmet varieties, such as the Joey's Brooklyn special, adorned with alfredo sauce, spinach, tomato, bacon, and mozzarella ($12.99 and up).

5229 Red Bug Lake Rd
Winter Springs,
FL
US

Super Suppers's staff of super cuisineers assembles fresh feasts daily for both meat-lovers and vegetarians. The healthy meals are then frozen for flawless later retrieval. The Winter Springs menu showcases entrees such as Asian tilapia ($14 for regular size), vegetarian lasagna ($14 for regular size), and cranberry hoisin chicken breasts ($14 for regular size). Finish off with a dessert of cinnamon monkey bread to satisfy stomachs and silence sweet teeth ($12 for regular size). Super Suppers also offers pre-made Grab n' Go entrees, sides, desserts, and breakfast items.

1295 Tuskawilla Rd
Winter Springs,
FL
US

Family owned Italian Eatery with Top Notch Italian Food, and Unmatched Customer Service.

1014 State Road 436
Casselberry,
FL
US