Italian Restaurants in Worthington

$18 for $30 Worth of Italian Fare at Cardone's Restaurant & Bar

Cardone's Restaurant & Bar

Westerville

Classic Italian dishes, such as arancini, scallop fresco, and chianti-braised lamb shank, are served in a friendly dining environment

$30 $18

View Deal

$11 for $20 Worth of Italian Bar Bites at Lucé Nuovo

Lucé Nuovo

Powell

Fried ravioli, crab-cake bites, stromboli, and Italian takes on burgers fill a new bar menu; live jazz on Thursday evenings

$20 $11

View Deal

Italian Food for Carry-Out or Delivery from Village Pizzeria (Up to 42% Off). Two Options Available.

Village Pizzeria

Dublin/Powell

Homemade dough, pasta, and sausage star in specialty pizzas, stuffed strombolis, ample slices of lasagna, and oven-baked subs

$19 $11

View Deal

$10 for $20 Worth of Italian Dinner for Two at Tony's Italian Ristorante

Tony's Italian Ristorante

Brewery District

Menu featuring homemade fettuccini with shrimp, scallops, and crab, veal saltimbocca with prosciutto and mozzarella, and salmon primavera

$20 $10

View Deal

$19 for a Take-N-Bake Pizza or Lasagna Meal from Mama Mimi's Take 'N Bake Pizza ($36 Value)

Mama Mimi's Take 'N Bake Pizza

Multiple Locations

Fresh-made pizza and lasagna that you can heat up and enjoy in the comfort of your home

$36 $19

View Deal

Pizza Dinner for Two or Four with Drinks or Takeout at bonoPIZZA (Up to 43% Off)

bonoPIZZA

Columbus

Hand-tossed, wood-fired 10” pizzas topped with ingredients such as coconut, sauerkraut, and fresh pesto

$22 $13

View Deal

Specialty Pizza Meals for Two or Four, or Take-Out or Delivery from Ange's Pizza - Clintonville (Up to 51% Off)

Anges Pizza - Clintonville

Clintonville

Custmoize pizzas with up to five toppings, paired with salads, appetizers, wings, and drinks; take-out and delivery option available

$25.05 $15

View Deal

$17 for $30 Worth of Pub Food and Non-Alcoholic Drinks at Plank's Bier Garten

Plank's Bier Garten

Brewery District

Bratwursts, burgers, braunschweiger sandwiches, and pizza headline menu at German Village mainstay

$30 $16

View Deal

Pizza and Pub Food at Gratzi a Tutti Pizzeria Bar & Sports (40% Off). Two Options Available.

Gratzi a Tutti Pizzeria Bar & Sports

Pickerington

Pizzas fired in a wood-burning oven, including one topped with housemade meatballs, plus pub classics and other Italian eats

$20 $12

View Deal

Pizza Packages with Options for Soda, Subs, and Salad at Taranto's Pizza (Up to 46% Off). Four Options Available.

Taranto's Pizza

South Columbus

Large one- or three- topping pizzas pair with side options like sodas, crisp salad, and fragrant garlic bread—or just more pizzas

$20.26 $12

View Deal

$10 for $20 Worth of Pizzas, Sandwiches, and Pasta at Captain 9’s

Captain 9's

Germantown

Pizza, pasta, Hershey's ice cream, and subs in a diner decorated with authentic firefighter suits

$20 $10

View Deal

$9.50 for $20 Worth of Pizza, Subs, and Drinks for Dine-In Service at Mio’s Pizzeria

Mio's Pizzeria

Miami Township

Original-crust pizza topped with wholesome cheese, tangy tomato sauce, and fresh ingredients

$20 $9.50

View Deal

Italian Cuisine at Lunch for Two at Ferrari’s Little Italy and Bakery (Up to 53% Off). Two Options Available.

Ferrari's Little Italy and Bakery

Madeira

Family-recipe Italian food, gelato, fresh-baked focaccia bread, and homemade pizzas served amid rustic exposed-brick walls and outdoor patio

$20 $11

View Deal

$11 for $20 Worth of Italian Food at Fairfield Pizza & Pasta Company

Fairfield Pizza & Pasta Company

Fairfield

Baked ziti and ravioli accompany signature pizzas such as the Deluxe, with pepperoni, bacon, sausage, and mushrooms

$20 $11

View Deal

$11 for Two Groupons, Each Good for $10 Worth of Cuisine at Papa Joe's Pizza ($20 Total Value)

Papa Joe's Pizza

Vermilion

Pizzeria dishes out meatball subs, grilled chicken salads, and pizza with toppings such as green olives, ham, pineapple, and bacon

$10 $5.50

View Deal

Pizza and Italian Food for Two or Four at Pizza Tower (Up to 48% Off)

Pizza Tower

Cincinnati

Chefs make pizzas from scratch with more than 30 toppings, including fresh mozzarella cheese

$20 $11

View Deal

$19.99 for a Pizza, Pasta, or Lasagna Meal from Mama Mimi's Take 'N Bake Pizza ($37.96 Value)

Mama Mimi's Take 'N Bake Pizza

Multiple Locations

Fresh-made pizza, lasagna, and other pastas that you can heat up and enjoy in the comfort of your home

$37.96 $19.99

View Deal

Italian and American Comfort Food at Meatball Kitchen (50% Off)

Meatball Kitchen

Cincinnati

Inventive menu starts with beef, turkey, spicy pork, or vegetarian meatballs, which can top pasta, salads, or decorate sandwiches

$14 $7

View Deal

$12 for $20 Worth of Pizza and Sandwiches at Tusculum Grille

Tusculum Grille

East End/Columbia Tusculum

Italian-style thin-crust specialty pizzas such as buffalo chicken, veggie, and vegan veggie

$20 $12

View Deal

Select Local Merchants

Papa Murphy’s, the highest-ranking pizza chain in the 2010 Zagat Fast-Food Survey, serves up a tasty menu of handmade Take 'n’ Bake pizzas made from dough, cheese, meat, and veggies that are freshly prepared every day. After customers choose their pie, Papa Murphy's slice-slingers build the pizza in-store and package it for customers to bake at home in the oven, in a pottery kiln, or over a pile of burning cookbooks. Customers can select one of Papa Murphy's signature pizzas or customize their 'za ($9.99 for a large with one topping) to a more specific taste, choosing from four sauces, three crusts, and more than 20 toppings.

6664 Perimeter Loop Rd
Dublin,
OH
US

Urbanspooners give Formaggio Pizza's Columbus location an 86% approval rating; the restaurant also has positive reviews on Nothing Better To Do and Grub Critic:

5875 Sawmill Rd
Dublin,
OH
US

Warm, natural woods, terra cotta, wrought-iron fixtures, and exposed ceiling beams lend the upscale eatery an Old World charm studded with pops of contemporary green chairs, red lamp shades, and ethereal purple lights glowing above the bar. Overlooking scenic Big Walnut Creek and its surrounding park, the dining room is a romantic and comfortable spot for first dates that's free of the stuffy atmosphere and snooty waiters commonly associated with date-night fare. For an even better view and more intimate outing, hit the outdoor patio, where a fire pit casts flattering light and warm fuzzies on couples, old friends, and former P.E. teachers.

12 W Bridge St
Dublin,
OH
US

In 1974, the founders of Mellow Mushroom were self-proclaimed hippies who devoted a lot of thought to what the perfect pizza would be like. The overarching criteria was simple: make the most "craveable slice of pizza on the planet." The crew opened their first shop in Atlanta, and have since expanded across the country. Each of their pizza outposts serve up pies such as the Kosmic Karma with feta cheese, spinach, sun-dried tomatoes, and a swirl of pesto. Mellow Mushroom's menu also includes hoagies with all-natural meats, as well as salads, "munchies," and beer, which can be sipped a la carte or as part of the restaurant's beer club.

6505 Dublin Center Dr
Dublin,
OH
US

Sturdy, huge, and basking in the warmth of candles suspended overhead, the community table inside Mia Cucina's Powell outpost is an apt metaphor for the community that frequents the restaurant. At both locations, a sense of hospitality vies with the aromas of house sauces to charm those who walk through the doors. Children—who dine gratis on Mondays and Wednesdays—peruse a specialized menu with mazes and games, absorbing trivia about Italy's climate, its inventions, and the volcanoes that spew marinara sauce. Adults scan their own menu, which embraces Italian staples along with more updated plates, from chicken parmesan to pesto-rubbed mahi-mahi fillets.

When they aren't browsing the cuisine, their eyes might linger on the shelves of the floating bar, where wine bottles and glasses levitate over the counter instead of bogarting the chairs. The surrounding wall mimics gray stonework, adding a rustic cellar ambiance to the setting, though the white cloths draped over each table bespeak modern sophistication. The murmur of conversations between families, friends, and couples pervades the genial space, where Mia Cucina insists "everyone's Italian."

5525 New Albany Road West
New Albany,
OH
US

Dough flips through the air, releasing a cumulonimbus of flour as it lands softly in the hands of chef David Zadnik, who crafts the crucial ingredient each day with help from local ingredients and family recipes. The heritage of the eatery doesn?t just shine through in culinary formulas; the walls at both locations shimmer with old family photos from David's basement and glossy sports memorabilia. Strains of Frank Sinatra spread out smoothly behind conversations in dining rooms dappled with warm wood accents, occasionally spilling out to an outdoor patio or across the Westerville location's outdoor bocce-ball court. Guests sit down for pastas, sandwiches, and suds from Great Lakes Brewery and Peroni, often unaware that these tables held a victory dinner for pugilist Buster Douglas when he returned from defeating Mike Tyson in Japan, but before he picked up his victory dry cleaning.

6000 Westerville Rd
Westerville,
OH
US