Italian Restaurants in Yucaipa

Select Local Merchants

At Two Guys Pasta and Pizza, tomato sauce simmers on the stove for hours, while housemade pizza dough bakes in the oven until bubbly and crisp. The eatery’s from-scratch sauces and breads have earned nods from the Daily Bulletin, which hails the fresh-baked bread as “outstanding—almost a meal in itself.” Diners can also make a meal out of Two Guys’ specialty pastas and sandwiches, pairing these eats with draft beers and bottles of wine freshly tapped from the grape bush.

2566 Highland Ave
Highland,
CA
US

Napoli Italian Restaurant summons the spirits of Old Country recipes by stirring up a menu of traditional Italian plates and pairable glasses from rackfuls of fine wines. Toasted bread dance floors hold aloft fresh tomato, garlic, oregano, and fresh basil atop an antipasto of bruschetta ($7.50). Patrons rest their incisors on a boneless bed of pollo marsala ($10.95) to dream of sweet marsala wine and dating the cute bicuspid across the jaw. Chunks of shrimp, calamari, scallops, clams, mussels, and salmon swim laps between strands of pasta in the linguini pescatore's pool of olive oil and light marinara or white sauce ($16.50). Oenophiles flex their matchmaking muscles by pairing varietals with their meal, marrying a full-bodied red to the milk-fed veal of the vitello piccata ($12.50) or setting up a glass of white with the baked chicken breast of the pollo florentina ($12.50).

24960 Redlands Blvd
Loma Linda,
CA
US

Wake snoozing taste buds with a hearty starter such as mozzarella suprema breadsticks adorned with natural cheese and herbs ($3.95 side; $5.95 large) before moving onto a signature fire-roasted pie. An authentic terra-cotta oven blasts RedBrick's prided circles with more than 1,000 degrees of heat, alchemically transforming their base dough into crispy gold in less than three minutes. Enjoy stationary drive-in dining with a bacon-cheeseburger pizza topped with ground beef and three kinds of cheese ($17.95 for a 14"), or graze on the veggie gourmet works, which comes loaded with a Peter Piper's worth of fresh vegetables including bell peppers, artichokes, and mushrooms, swaddled in your choice of a vegetarian red or white sauce ($17.95 for a 14"). Create-your-own pies are also available, providing palate-pleasing fill-in-the-blanks for the munching mad-libbest. Yowling sweet teeth can be silenced with a dessert of gourmet gelato or a surprise dinner visit from the dentist's wife, the librarian.

5244 University Pkwy
San Bernardino,
CA
US

Hand-tossed dough sails sky-high at Bonello’s New York Pizza, where chefs pepper pies in an oregano-based herb blend sealed in by the flickering flames from a stone oven. Dining companions can peruse the menu’s inspired litany of toppings—which include balsamic marinated steak, cashews, and pineapple—which drift across eight hefty New York–style slices ($10.95+) or a Sicilian–style pizza doused in homemade marinara. Like an underachieving yardstick, Bonello’s hot and cold sandwiches span 18 inches and stuff themselves with hearty mounds of homemade meatballs, Neapolitan cold cuts, and sweet italian sausage ($4.95+/half, $6.95/whole). Marinara and melted mozzarella ooze over a tender trio of ricotta-stuffed manicotti tubes ($8.95), where ropes of angel-hair pasta lope themselves around chopped roma tomatoes, garlic, and basil ($8.95+). Those looking to feast in the comfort of their own castles can place on an order for pickup on Bonello’s nifty online order form, an accommodating alternative to ordering via phone or smoke signal.

22413 Barton Rd
Grand Terrace,
CA
US

199 N State St
Hemet,
CA
US

John's Incredible Pizza Co. graces guests with acres of incandescent entertainment options and a fully stocked buffet ($9.49 value, $1.50 value for drinks). In addition to a slew of soups, salads, pasta, desserts, and traditional pizza choices, the buffet brandishes a bouquet of specialty pizza creations, including spicy peanut-butter, barbecue chicken ranch, and alfredo pizza.

6187 Valley Springs Pkwy
Riverside,
CA
US