About this Business
From Our Editors
Batavia Creamery began its life as a Baskin-Robbins in 1991, but even 31 flavors proved too limiting to the shop’s ambitious owners. They rebranded and went independent, boosting their flavor count to 44 and supplementing their traditional cones and cups with thick shakes, smoothies, and custom cakes. Though the flavors are subject to change, there’s always something for everyone—recent cakes and pies have included praline-pecan, mint-chocolate-chip, and cookies ‘n’ cream varieties. The shop also sells its creations in take-home pints and quarts, which customers can keep for themselves or use to play fetch with the neighborhood kids.