Mill Creek Tavern

275 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709 Directions
+15166282000
Be the first to recommend this place!
92% of 381 customers recommended

Now This Is Something Special

Mill Creek Tavern has a treat for you!
Happy Hour
Monday - Friday | 4:30 PM - 7:00 PM
$1.50 off all drinks
1/2 price bar menu, excluding bar steak
Early Evening Prix Fixe
4:30 PM - 6:30 PM
$24.95 for 3-course prix fixe meal.
Pasta Specials
Tuesday
$12.95 for any pasta entrée. Includes House or Caesar salad.
Show all 7 available specials
Wine & Steak Special
Wednesday
Half-price any bottle of wine
$16.95 Steak "n" Potatoes: grilled filet mignon tips, mashed potatoes, and veggies
Girls Night Out Special
Thursday
$5 skinny margaritas and cosmos
$14.95 BBQ 1/2 chicken, cole slaw, & sweet potato fries
All Night Happy Hour
Saturday | 4:30 PM - 2:00 AM
$1.50 off all drinks
1/2 price bar menu, excluding bar steak
$3 Bud drafts
$5 house wine
Lobster Special
Sunday
$24.95 includes choice of:
wedge salad or lobster bisque
1 1/2lb steamed Maine lobster
baked... Read More
$24.95 includes choice of:
wedge salad or lobster bisque
1 1/2lb steamed Maine lobster
baked potatoes
corn on the cob
drawn butter
$5 cold draft or house wine

About this business

  • Cuisine
    American, Grill, Seafood, Steak, Pub Food
  • Meals
    Dinner
  • Website
    millcreekny.com
  • Price
    $$$$$
  • Cuisine
    American, Grill, Seafood, Steak, Pub Food
  • Meals
    Dinner
  • Show More
  • Attire
    Casual
  • Alcohol
    Available
  • Parking
    Street
  • Delivery
    No
  • Takeout
    Yes
  • Reservations
    Yes
  • Catering
    Yes
  • Good For Kids
    Yes
  • Good For Groups
    Yes
  • Show Less

Tips

250
Verified
Report | a month ago
great food
Verified
Report | 2 months ago
The food is incredible, service is always top-notch. If you aren't from the area, Mill Creek is DEFINITELY worth the ride into Bayville.
Report | 2 months ago
Excellent Restaurant. Always a family favorite
Verified
Report | 3 months ago
Mussel pots were delicious!!! Service was excellent!!
Verified
Report | 3 months ago
Good was fantastic!! Service was excellent!! Will definitely return !!
Verified
Report | 4 months ago
Great service and amazing food! The wait staff was so helpful! Would love to go back
Verified
Report | 6 months ago
Excellent meals.
Verified
Report | 6 months ago
Parking is an issue, but we eventually found a spot on the street
Verified
Report | 6 months ago
Cozy n great food
Verified
Report | 6 months ago
Go hungry. So many incredible regular menu items plus above&beyond specials. Today the sauerbraten boneless short ribs were melt in your mouth delicious accompanied w fresh red cabbage that dare I say rivaled my nanas'. We come from Melville to enjoy their luscious cuisine. Graciously yours, Bob&Loretta
Showing 1-10 of 86 tips
Show 10 more tips

From Our Editors

Mill Creek Tavern?s nautically themed dining room excites the eyes with model ships, wood crackling in a stone fireplace, and the restaurant?s logo of crossed canoe paddles. Meanwhile, the aroma of freshly caught seafood and juicy steaks on the grill signals the feast to come, much like the smell of cigar smoke signals a spritz of Winston Churchill cologne. A part of the Mim?s family of restaurants, Mill Creek Tavern has been a Bayville staple for more than a quarter century. One of the tavern?s owners is always onsite holding the entrees to a consistently lofty standard, inspiring a rave review from Joanne Starkey of The New York Times, who recommended ?the fall-from-the-bones-tender baby-back ribs, a perfectly grilled fillet of lemon sole, and a rousing rendition of chicken scarpariello with meat on the bone and lots of garlic, sausage, and potatoes.?

Is this your business?
Claim this page to add your promotions and content

Explore Nearby Deals Near Mill Creek Tavern

This is one of the most popular merchants on Groupon and is highly recommended by customers
To receive $1 in Groupon Bucks, let us know that you're going to use one of these Specials and then tell us about your experience at this business.
A Groupon Buck is site credit worth $1 that's deposited directly into your Groupon account. If you have Groupon Bucks available, they'll be applied automatically at checkout for any deal except Getaways Market Picks. Please note that you can only earn one Groupon Buck per business from Specials.
  • $ -$15
  • $$ $15-$30
  • $$$ $30-$50
  • $$$$ $50-$75
  • $$$$$ $75+
Groupon has verified that the customer actually visited Mill Creek Tavern.
Follow this business to hear the latest and find out if they have a great offer for you.
Many people described the Skirt Steak as Awesome.
+ 50%
- 50%


Many people described the Risotto as Crunchy.
+ 67%
- 33%


Many people described the Tuna as Perfect.
+ 67%
- 33%


Many people described the Scallops as Nice. Others thought:
+ 67%

  • Nice
- 33%

  • Small
Many people described the Booth as Private.
+ 83%
- 17%


Many people described the Seafood as Nice.
+ 67%
- 33%


+ 33%
- 67%


Many people described the Ambiance as Nice.
+ 88%
- 12%


+ 50%
- 50%


Many people described the Music as Friendly.
+ 75%
- 25%