From Our Editors
Citarella is a casual restaurant located on Montauk Highway in Water Mill. With wonderful seafood and tasty salad, this restaurant won't let you down. It's a popular restaurant for visitors seeking good food.
When the New York weather is cooperating, guests have spoken very highly about the available outdoor seating.
If you need food provided for a local event, take advantage of its catering options.
A favorite in Water Mill, a trip to Citarella is definitely worthwhile.