Cutest Cookies

New Dorp Beach

Give as a Gift
Limited quantity available
Over 120 bought

In a Nutshell

Bakers craft batches of butter cookies from 11 peanut-free ingredients before hand-painting them with custom designs

The Fine Print

Promotional value expires Mar 28, 2012. Amount paid never expires. Limit 1 per person, may buy 2 additional as gifts. Valid only for option purchased. Must order 1 week in advance. Merchant is solely responsible to purchasers for the care and quality of the advertised goods and services.

Decorated cookies can express all kinds of sentiments, from hearts that say “I love you” to Christmas trees that say “I buried your car keys in the forest.” Send someone a message to chew on with today’s Groupon to Cutest Cookies, located inside Hylan Plaza on Staten Island. Choose from the following options:

  • For $12, you get one dozen custom-made cookies (up to a $27 value).
  • For $22, you get two dozen custom-made cookies (up to a $54 value).
  • For $32, you get three dozen custom-made cookies (up to an $81 value).

This deal is valid only for cookies priced up to $2.25, but upgrades are available for an additional fee.

Cutest Cookie’s crafty bakers bring butter cookies to life with fresh ingredients, creative cookie themes, and hand-painted designs. Whipping together 11 peanut-free ingredients, including butter, sugar, eggs, and vanilla, confectioners churn out sweets with custom designs ranging from birthdays and holidays to everyday images, such as flowers, monkeys, and monkeys made of flowers. Each delicious treat is then tucked into a clear cellophane bag and secured with a matching, curled ribbon to ensure optimal freshness. Batches of sugary disks are baked 1–2 days prior to pickup and remain fresh up to one month if properly stored at room temperature and given daily affirmations of their endless beauty.

Cutest Cookies

Don't let the name fool you: butter cookies are made from more than just butter. At Cutest Cookies, each nut-free, from-scratch batch incorporates 10 ingredients, including vanilla, flour, and meringue powder. Customers determine every cookie's color, shape, and design, ranging from wedding cookies decorated like tuxedos and dresses to birthday cookies ornamented with replicated pictures of the birthday boy or girl.

Bakers make the order one to two days before a customer's event, hand-decorating each cookie with individually mixed icing colors. To ensure freshness, they place every cookie in a cellophane bag fastened with a matching ribbon. If left in original packaging, an airtight container, or your mouth unchewed, the cookies will stay fresh for an entire month.

Customer Reviews

The owner Christine is always a pleasure to work with.
Susan A. · January 10, 2017
Excellent product. Awesome value. Amazing people work there.
Marie W. · December 16, 2016
Amazing Cookies! They really are cute and taste great too! Thank you!
Stacey T. · October 19, 2016
Merchant Location Map
  1. 1

    New Dorp Beach

    2600 Hylan Boulevard

    New York, NY 10306


    Get Directions

By purchasing this deal you'll unlock points which can be spent on discounts and rewards. Every 5,000 points can be redeemed for $5 Off your next purchase.