Fenik's Frozen Custard

Bay Village

Give as a Gift
Limited quantity available
Over 270 bought

In a Nutshell

At an old-fashioned ice-cream parlor, customers sample 39 rotating frozen-custard flavors such as chocolate-cake batter or pistachio

The Fine Print

Promotional value expires Jun 1, 2016. Amount paid never expires. Limit 1 per person, may buy 1 additional as gift. May redeem across visits, or all cones at once. Valid only for option purchased. Not valid on Mother's Day, 5/8/16. Merchant is solely responsible to purchasers for the care and quality of the advertised goods and services.

Choose Between Two Options

  • $11 for a punch card for five small frozen custard cones ($20 value)
  • $20 for a punch card for ten small frozen custard cones ($40 value)

Sugar smiths top cones with creamy creations, cycling through flavors such as salty caramel truffle, chocolate blackout, coconut avalanche, and raspberry truffle. In addition to the cream and sugar found in ice cream, custard uses eggs to make for a smoother texture. With 39 rotating flavors, customers can pick up a flavor listing a schedule of when and what flavors will be featured.

Fenik's Frozen Custard

Since the traditional soda shop has fallen by the wayside, ice-cream parlors have become one of the sole guardians of childhood sweets-induced bliss. Though they founded it in 2004, the owners of Fenik's Frozen Custard take that responsibility seriously, doing their best to summon up friendly nostalgia with the historic photos covering their mint-green walls and the checkerboard floor underfoot. They even outfitted the joint with chrome-finished tables and chairs, a popular style from the 1950s and a 1960 Seeburg Jukebox with original 45" discs that is set on free play. The staff cycles through different custard flavors every week, whipping up new batches based on recently discovered recipes or just their own imagination. Apart from nearby parking spaces, a bike rack out front also makes the joint accessible for sweets-craving youngsters.

Customer Reviews

This has got to be the best ice creme ever! We love the chocolate carmel cashew the best. Soon it's chocolate turtle as flavor of the week and we'll be there a lot!
Karen M. · July 30, 2016
Great cream.
Paul L. · July 20, 2016
The frozen custard is wonderful at Fenik's. I highly recommend them.
MARYELLEN A. · June 1, 2016

By purchasing this deal you'll unlock points which can be spent on discounts and rewards. Every 5,000 points can be redeemed for $5 Off your next purchase.