An honest first look review: I wear a size 9.5, due to the reviews of others that had said to order a full size or half a size down than what you normally wear, I ordered a size 8.5. I have about a half an inch room from the tip of the shoe to my big toe, so it fits wonderfully. If you don't want a little extra room, order a size and a half down from what you normally wear. They fail to include that this particular Chelsea boot is more of a pointed toe vs the round toe, so keep that in mind. As far as comfort, sure they feel good, but I can't attest to wearing them all day. They are a narrow style shoe, feminine looking, but anyone can pull them off with the right jeans or pants. You get your money's worth! Hope this helps as some of the other reviews weren't so helpful. I gave 4 stars due to not knowing how well these will hold up in time and not wearing them for a length of time to see how comfortable they truly are. They are not true to size.