I ordered the Black in size 8.5 (the box even says black/8.5) but in the box was a pair of Cognac size 9! They run small so the 9 is actually a better fit. But since I don't like color, I'll be returning them. They are very cute but I agree with other reviewers - they are cheap looking and very thin. I doubt they'd keep my feet very warm.
My biggest disappointment in the boots is that they did not fit. I ordered a size 9 and they were to small. A friend who wears a 9 said that they fit her perfectly, so she is buying them from me. They looked better on the pic that in person due to the material. She likes them, so I guess that was a good thing.