Haunted Trail Of Horrors

Middle Island

82 Ratings

Value Discount You Save
$20 50% $10
Give as a Gift
Limited quantity available
Over 260 bought

In a Nutshell

Brave thrill-seekers go on a hunt to explore the mysterious and spooky legend of the Abelwhite family

The Fine Print

Promotional value expires Oct 30, 2015. Amount paid never expires. Limit 1 per person, may buy 1 additional as a gift. Limit 1 per visit. Valid only for option purchased. Available for use beginning the day after purchase. Must use promotional value in 1 visit. Merchant is solely responsible to purchasers for the care and quality of the advertised goods and services.

Choose from Three Options

  • $10 for admission to the Haunted Trail of Horrors for two ($20 value)
  • $20 for admission to the Haunted Trail of Horrors for four ($40 value)
  • $40 for admission to the Haunted Trail of Horrors for eight ($80 value)

Haunted Trail of Horrors

The forests around Middle Island are pretty peaceful during most of the year. But come October, screams start coming from the trees—reminding townsfolk of the tale of Hilton and Jasper Abelwhite. According to legend, this father and son lived in the woods behind Nathaniel Johnson's farm, where things mysteriously went missing: first it was chickens, then some crops, and then people—but at least no dogs were harmed.

The Middle Island Fire Department's Haunted Trail of Horrors takes brave visitors into the heart of this story. For 15–20 minutes, they intrepidly follow a dimly lit path that leads to where the Abelwhites had their camp, and there are plenty of scares along the way. Though the terrors change every year, you can check out photos from past trails to get a taste of what's in store.

Customer Reviews

82 Ratings

It was a great scare and perfect for an October visit. They did a terrific job with the costumes, decorations and props. It was a quick walk through (about 10-15 minutes) but enjoyable. My only complaint was the wait on line but I guess many haunted events have lines the week before Halloween.
Jennifer H. · November 9, 2016
brought some 12 year olds for a birthday and they all had a great time!
Katherine M. · November 2, 2016
Great time and its actually a fundraiser for the fire house, so you feel good about supporting them as well!
Elizabeth N. · October 30, 2016
Merchant Location Map
  1. 1

    Middle Island

    31 Arnold Drive

    Middle Island, NY 11953


    Get Directions

Thrilling and heart-pounding experiences
15% Bonus Savings
Get an extra 15% off local restaurants, spas, salons, and more to use within 48 hours of your Goods order! See details
By purchasing this deal you'll unlock points which can be spent on discounts and rewards. Every 5,000 points can be redeemed for $5 Off your next purchase.