Mill Creek Tavern


405 Ratings

Value Discount You Save
$50 50% $25
Give as a Gift
Limited quantity available
Over 170 bought

In a Nutshell

Bayville staple serves hearty helpings of tender steak, Prince Edward Island mussels, and seafood pot pie with lobster, shrimp, and scallops

The Fine Print

Promotional value expires Nov 1, 2014. Amount paid never expires. Reservation required. Limit 1 per person. Limit 1 per table. Valid only for option purchased. Must be seated prior to 6 P.M. on Fridays and Saturdays. Not valid on Holidays, Prix Fixe or special nights. Not valid with Restaurant Week Menu. Not valid with other offers or promotions. Merchant is solely responsible to purchasers for the care and quality of the advertised goods and services.

Choose Between Two Options

  • $25 for $50 worth of steak and seafood for dinner, valid Tuesday–Thursday or Sunday
  • $40 for $60 worth of steak and seafood for dinner, valid any day
  • Click to see the menu.

Mill Creek Tavern

Mill Creek Tavern’s nautically themed dining room excites the eyes with model ships, wood crackling in a stone fireplace, and the restaurant’s logo of crossed canoe paddles. Meanwhile, the aroma of freshly caught seafood and juicy steaks on the grill signals the feast to come, much like the smell of cigar smoke signals a spritz of Winston Churchill cologne. A part of the Mim’s family of restaurants, Mill Creek Tavern has been a Bayville staple for more than a quarter century. One of the tavern’s owners is always onsite holding the entrees to a consistently lofty standard, inspiring a rave review from Joanne Starkey of The New York Times, who recommended “the fall-from-the-bones-tender baby-back ribs, a perfectly grilled fillet of lemon sole, and a rousing rendition of chicken scarpariello with meat on the bone and lots of garlic, sausage, and potatoes.”

Customer Reviews

405 Ratings

Great food and friendly people Live music at the bar often
Eleanor M. · September 21, 2015
The food was delicious! I had the pan seared sea scallops and really enjoyed it! We will def go back!
Kristen P. · June 20, 2015
Our meal was delicious. Vanessa, our server, was very helpful and made us feel at home.
Nick S. · April 24, 2015
Merchant Location Map
  1. 1


    275 Bayville Ave

    Unit A

    Bayville, NY 11709


    Get Directions

Impress your date with romantic restaurants and activities for two
Bring your besties for these all-in activities
15% Bonus Savings
Get an extra 15% off local restaurants, spas, salons, and more to use within 48 hours of your Goods order! See details
By purchasing this deal you'll unlock points which can be spent on discounts and rewards. Every 5,000 points can be redeemed for $5 Off your next purchase.