The staffers at Mr. Pickle’s Sandwich Shop layer their five styles of in-house-baked breads with creative ingredient combinations that play with sweet, salty, and rich flavors. Specialty sandwiches include the Hang Loose—pastrami with bacon, cream cheese, and avocado—and the Hot T—hot turkey smothered in melted pepper jack cheese and baja and cranberry sauce.

But clients can try their hand at their own creations, choosing from eight sandwich meats and six cheeses. From there, they can add toppings that range from traditional lettuce and pickles to more avant garde selections such as cranberries and the house's signature garlic sauce, which doubles as vampire repellent.