- $19 for one medium pizza with three toppings, plus garlic bread, and a two-liter soda ($29.23 value)
The pizzas at Mustafio's may be Sicilian-style, but, thanks to the plethora of unique topping choices, they're also uniquely San Francisco. Here, you're just as likely to see roasted yellow peppers, feta cheese, and chipotle sauce adorning a pie as you are classic toppings such as pepperoni, basil, and black olives. Customers can build-their-own delicious masterpiece or choose from specialty pizzas like the Chicken Pesto, crowned with chicken, pesto, garlic, corn, and green peppers. For good measure, the kitchen also whips up other eats like salads and meatball subs in addition to its pizzas, and serves it all to hungry groups until three in the morning.