Choose Between Two Options
- $14 for $20 worth of takeout
- $25 for $50 worth of catering
- See the menus
Sleepy Hollow Delly
A testament to the deep love the community feels for Sleepy Hollow Delly can be measured in pounds––about 2,000 of them; their famous homemade potato salad is produced on-site and sold by the ton around the holidays. Passed down through three generations, the Gruwells originally opened the deli back in 1957, and little has changed aside from the faces behind the counter. Still in its original location, the classic interior is home to little booths where diners can enjoy sandwiches from a list of more than 150 and some of that famous potato salad, among a whole host of other prepared foods. Sleepy Hollow also offers catering services, delivering platters of meatball sandwiches, lunch-meat trays, hoagie trays, and desserts to corporate events, birthday parties, and family eating contests.