Tootie Pie Co. (Benny's Bagels)

Multiple Locations

Give as a Gift
Limited quantity available
Over 1,000 bought

In a Nutshell

  • Complete meal for two
  • Scrumptious bagels
  • Toothsome pie
  • Good for two locations

The Fine Print

Promotional value expires Sep 30, 2010. Amount paid never expires. Limit 2 per person, may buy additional as gifts. Not valid with other offers. Merchant is solely responsible to purchasers for the care and quality of the advertised goods and services.

Before pie was invented, ancient mathematicians were forced to use salads to make circular calculations, leading to chaos, croutons, and catastrophic circumferences. Today’s Groupon celebrates humanity's passage into enlightenment. For $12, you get a meal for two, including two enbageled or paninied sandwiches (up to a $16 value), two drinks (a $4 value), and two toothsome slices of pie (a $10 value) from Tootie Pie Co. Gourmet Café. Tootie Pie Co. inhabits a netherworldly zone within the ghostly shapes of the two former Benny's Bagels shops off Highway 281 North and at Bitters.

Because the pie and the circle share such a close relationship, bagels too are capable vehicles for stuffing full of goopy, yummy goodness. All of Tootie Pie's bagels are made from flour and yeast, boiled in a steel caldron, and fresh-toasted. Commence your meal with the jalapeno-pimento bagel sandwich, or indulge in Waldorf-style chicken salad with red grapes and pecans on a croissant. Vegetarians can dig into a portobello mushroom panini, or warm up with Tootie's signature soup—roasted red pepper and smoked ghouda bisque. To embrace the rectangle instead, reach no further than the prosciutto tomato panini with basil pesto or house-made chipolte mayo.

The pies are the true crustocopia at this feast for two, with an array of selections each handcrafted from scratch with fresh ingredients. Meek forks and spoons bend and shudder under the heft of thick cream custard in the buttermilk pie, while the few utensil survivors cross the silky, cream-cheese expanse of a lemon velvet slice in search of the promised land. To keep your sweet exploration classy, take up the apple pie's dare to discover the secret flavors in its buttery, flaky crust and cinnamon-spiced apple slivers.


Recent Yelpers and Urbanspooners love the additions that Tootie Pie Co. Gourmet Café on Huebner Road and Evans Road have made to the former Benny's Bagels:

  • Like that they are now serving pie by the slice, love it with my latte. Also, have always enjoyed the music here. – graybi11, Urbanspoon
  • Enoyed the panini's and wraps. Started serving Tootie Pie this month! – graybi11, Urbanspoon
  • Tootie Pie's Pecan Pie is soo amazingly good. I could eat a whole pie by myself and hold all others at bay with a knife. Really you must try a slice or a whole pie. – Leticia O., Yelp

Tootie Pie

Ruby Lorraine Feagan, better known as Tootie, began her business by building one pie at a time. Her reputation gained momentum after winning a succession of baking contests throughout Texas hill country. Her signature apple pie, containing up to 3 pounds of apples, was the foundation for Tootie Pie Co. Today, Tootie and her daughter continue to ensure the quality of Tootie Pie Co. with 12 signature pie flavors.

Customer Reviews

Awesome pies, hands down!
Cynthia D. · June 27, 2016
Gluten free crust cherry pie is great.
Martha L. · July 28, 2015
Great helpful staff and great variety
Maria A O. · December 30, 2014
Merchant Location Map
  1. 1

    Far North Central

    16615 Huebner Rd

    San Antonio, Texas 78248

    Get Directions
  2. 2

    Far North Central

    2339 E. Evans Rd

    San Antonio, Texas 78259

    Get Directions

By purchasing this deal you'll unlock points which can be spent on discounts and rewards. Every 5,000 points can be redeemed for $5 Off your next purchase.