These are absolutely awful, I bought some bully sticks on this Grpupon site they were called Best Bully Sticks and they were wonderful the sticks were packaged in a nice heavy bag like you buy from a retail store and the stick were lovely dark brown and nice size, my dogs are very fussy and I was so surprised when both of them loved these right off. This brand I just got which I thought was the same as I got before so that was my mistake came in a clear plastic bag with a bar code sticker on it and that was all. the sticks are light brown and neither of my dogs will even take one from me. of course it was a final sale so in the trash these go and I am out 50 dollars because I thought I was reordering my previous. stick so I ordered 2 pks I am new to Groupon and this has really put a bad taste in my mouth. I don't think I will be buying anything from them again. Please be careful to order the correct ones and I think you will be happy.