Fresh-baked pies were recently named America’s third favorite dessert, ranking just behind pie-flavored milkshakes and frozen pie-sicles. Opt for a delicious, old-fashioned dessert with today’s Groupon: for $9, you get two homemade pies at Mazzetti’s Bakery in Pacifica (a $19.90 value).

All-natural ingredients and fresh fruits abound at Mazzetti’s Bakery, where pastry chefs concoct freshly baked pies on a daily basis. Crisp, golden crust ensconces any number of fresh fillings—including cherry, peach, pumpkin, and boysenberry—that emit coiling cartoon aromas designed to lure reclusive neighbors and the bear that played Gentle Ben. Though today’s Groupon only involves pies, Mazzetti’s also targets sweet teeth with custom cakes and holiday-themed desserts and aims to silence trilling tummies with savory slices of fresh Italian–style focaccia.